MovieChat Forums > Murder One (1995) Discussion > WHY did they replace Daniel Benzali??

WHY did they replace Daniel Benzali??


I was absolutely RIVETED by this series....the story line, the acting, the DRAMA....but WHY did they replace Daniel??? My GOD, what an actor!!

I'm pre-ordering this on DVD from Amazon.com - it's about time!

reply

[deleted]

I remember reading that Daniel was not the easiest person with whom to work at the time Season One was filmed, so his leaving was sort of a mutual decision.

I have never seen Season Two...I'd like to at some time, but after Daniel left and the format changed I wasn't interested in watching when it originally aired. I imagine I would have felt the same way if "24" had been changed (thank heavens the producers thought better of that bad idea!). It's the you-must-see-every-episode-or-you'll-miss-something-important style that draws me in...and I suspect a lot of other people as well.

reply

[deleted]

Benzali was the best thing about this show. What I read was that focus groups liked the show but did not like him. So the network and/or the studio told Bochco to recast the lead or they wouldn't renew the show. They wanted a character who was better looking that could pull in female viewers and someone that could generate romantic tension with Mary McCormack's character. The show just wasn't the same without him. Benzali did not leave willingly. That stuff about him being difficult to work with is a total lie. Never believe the producers when they say it was a mutual decision.

reply

Well, the focus groups were idiots then! You were NOT supposed to like the Teddy character. He was supposed to be the hard-bitten lawyer that you loved to hate (think about his character on NYPD Blue).

I'm watching the DVD commentary right now (yes, I LOVE my DVDs!), and it's really clear that Benzali loved the show and was thrilled to do the role. Doesn't sound like a Bochco/Caruso situation at all (which was the way I recall a lot of people painted it at the time).

Well, it just sucks. It would be like replacing Kiefer on "24"...and it obviously had the same effect. The show flopped...not because it was put up against "ER", but because they took away the major reason we cared about it...which was Benzali and the one-trial format. What a shame. I'm not knocking LaPaglia--he's a great actor and I enjoy watching him on "Without a Trace". He's just not Benzali.

reply

[deleted]

If there was any tension between Benzali and Bochco it must have cleared up, because Benzali made semi-regular appearances on NYPD Blue for years after he left Murder One.

reply

I'm a 40 y.o. lawyer with a practice that involves little litigation. I must admit that I use Daniel Benzali's character to inspire me when i need to reassure a client in trouble. His cool confidence and near fatherly tone is very appropriate in some circumstances.

I have seen little of him out of playing lawyer but I know one thing, he sure has the looks and the attitude for these parts.

I'm also impressed about his physical behavior. His economy of motion and his facial expressions are a wonder to look at.

I hope he shows up again on network TV.

reply

OMG, He was SO beyond amazing!!! He *made* the series,and even when I first watched 'Murder One' when I was 9 years old, I just couldn't take my eyes off him for one second - I don't know what it is, but when he appears on the screen, he demands everyone's attention - wow, he's simply class!! I never even saw series 2, and I'm not sure I want to if Benzali's not in it!! What a brill actor!

reply

I think whatever the reason it was a bad one to replace Daniel..the whole thing about him was the air of confidence and respect and that was just the body language.The whole thing was that he was NOT the the stereotype pretty boy, was what made him riveting to watch.Everyone in the show was brilliant but Daniel was the pivot on which even Richard Cross ( S.Tucci)revolved..without him I lost interest fast and I do like Anthony la Pagila but it lost its oomph and its integrity without Daniel and I thought that doomed the show.

Whatever he is doing he will be forever remembered by fans of this show..which includes me..for his absolute prefect performance.

reply

I disagree with the idea that you weren't supposed to like him. His role as Ted Hoffman was much more nuanced then the lawyer he plaed on NYPD Blue, which was more of a stereotype. I think Hoffman was a very likable character many times, yet somewhat shadier when it came to matters of the ethcial grey matter of legal procedurals sometimes that lawyers find themselves in...but even then it was pretty easy to sympathize with him as you could see the bind his character was in.

reply

Ted Hoffman had a basic code of ethics; he never wanted to use blatantly underhanded means to get the verdict he wanted. Remember when the young intern leaks the information to the press? Teddy doesn't fire him. But when the boy leaks the fake porn tape to humiliate the reporter woman (which actually HELPED Neil Avedon's case by being an obvious fake), Teddy promptly fires him. He tells him, "You are deceitful and underhanded, so you will probably have a successful career, but not at this firm."
It also said a lot about him when Grasso temporarily quit the case. Rather than deal with some sneaky, sleazy D.A., he wanted her on the case because she is honest and ethical (even though this means that his job is going to be that much harder to get Neil off... he wants a fair fight rather than a dirty one).
Look at the associates he hires...with the exception of Justine, who temporarily becomes friends with Richard Cross, they are honest, bright, and not terribly power-hungry (especially for young associates working at such a powerful firm).
Teddy goes to bat for the cop who replaces his murdered private P.I. - he almost always fights to do the right thing. And he definitely wants what is best for Julie Costello, Francesca Cross, and, most importantly, his wife and daughter.
He's not perfect, but I think that we, the viewer, are supposed to get past his cold, flat demeanor to see the good man and brilliant lawyer underneath.

reply

I've just finished watching Series 1 of Murder One for the first time. I have to say I wasn't overly impressed with Daniel Benzali. Thats not suggesting he's a bad actor in any way, I just felt he was a little 'one-note' throughout the series.

Stanley Tucci on the other hand stood head and shoulders above everyone, displaying a wide range of emotions, each very convincingly.

In fact, now I'm typing this I'm beginning to see why Ted Hoffman was so constant in his demeanour. Its the people around him that have the more extremer reactions. Ted is the hub of the wheel, and everything revolved around him, and the further away from him the faster and more out of control people are.

I still feel there wasn't much emotional identity to found with Hoffman, but as a series it remained pretty enjoyable.

reply

I heard that American audiences just couldn't cope with a show that had a main character who didn't have 'movie star' good looks. I think Daniel Benzali was fantastic in Murder One, and I too didn't bother watching season 2. He may not have been stunning looking but his character was fascinating, and his voice was incredibly sexy too.


Nicely understated that. Like a bomb made out of jazz and feathers.

reply

I just finished watching the First Season and am one disc into Season two. I, too, feel that the series lost some of its punch with the departure of Daniel Benzali. I, for one, thought he had tremendous sex appeal and a commanding performance. The show was brilliant and I am now wanting to see everything he has appeared in. There is an article about Patricia Clarkson in the new issue of "More" magazine as she is coming in a new movie re-make of "All the King's Men" this fall. They made a huge mistake in re-casting the lead. Think of the Sopranos without Tony!!!!

reply

IMO, Season 2 was just as riveting as Season 1. Pruitt Taylor Vince as the serial killer, Clifford Banks, was superb. I even found myself sympathizing with him from time to time, which surprised me. I would definitely recommend Season 2 to anyone who enjoyed Season 1. And BTW, Anthony LaPaglia wasn't supposed to be like Daniel Benzali. Two different actors, two different approaches. I found them both captivating.

reply

As much as I like Anthony LaPaglia, he was no substitute for Benzali, and look at what happened. This was at the same time that the other best show on television, "Profiler" also lost its lead and swiftly collapsed. I wonder if Ally Walker and Daniel Benzali have ever met? They should; they have a lot in common to talk about!

reply

I heard that American audiences just couldn't cope with a show that had a main character who didn't have 'movie star' good looks.


I don't believe that, not when Dennis Franz was the lead on "NYPD Blue" for most of it's twelve year run, or Jerry Orbach was the main detective on "Law & Order" for a good twelve years, or James Gandolfini was Tony Soprano for eight years.

Benzali as Ted Hoffman, was one of the most (if not the most) exceptionally charismatic attorneys I've seen in TV or movies which far outweighed any "movie star looks".

Having a head of hair has little or no bearing on how powerful an actor's performance can be (look at Patrick Stewart!)

I don't really think Anthony LaPlagia did a bad job. I just don't think it was the right fit for him. ("Without a Trace" suits him much better).

The problem wasn't just replacing the lead. They also screwed with the format by dealing with multiple cases in a season, rather than one as they did in season one, which was one of the things that made "Murder One" original. I think this was because people found it hard to follow. They apparently learned how when "24" and other serialized shows turned up a few years later, but for whatever reason, couldn't here. Putting it up against "ER" (back in the George Clooney days, no less!) probably didn't help.

reply

I have been watching the Killing and it was brought up about other crime dramas that follow one case the entire season and it brought to mind Murder One.

I just wanted to chime in on Daniel Benzali and how disappointed I was when he left the show. I thought he was incredibly sexy and has a fierce intelligence. And my God...the man's voice gave me shivers!

Another show I enjoyed watching where the lead was not considered to be Hollywood handsome was Shark. I think both James Woods and Daniel Benzali are sexy, intelligent, talented men and I would watch any show either of them was on.

reply

I decided to re-watch Murder One too after watching The Killing.

I find the comments that women didn't find Daniel Benzali sexy hard to believe. When this show was on everyone in my office watched it and when I say all the women (over 30 of us, ages ranging from early 20s to late 50s) found him extremely sexy I'm not kidding.

Also I couldn't agree more about the man's voice. We had more than a few discussions about his sexy voice in my office.

reply

Unsure why they replaced Benzali but he was a hard act to follow.

Its that man again!!

reply

I don't think producer Steven Bochco had anything to do with Daniel Benzali's dismissal from "Murder One." Bochco fought the networks to have Benzali cast in the Ted Hoffman role in the first place.

In the case of Daniel Benzali, it was the ABC network that made an utterly stupid decision to cast a younger, more attractive romantic lead actor with more hair. Anthony LaPaglia is a talented actor but Benzali was born to play that role. I thought the network blew it by replacing Benzali. Benzali never got his acting career back on course after leaving "Murder One" and an actor of his unique talents didn't deserve being banished to a career of second tier television roles simply because the ABC network believed that Benzali didn't appeal to the right age demographic. I'm said to say that Benzali's are currently wasted in his role in the daytime soap opera, "General Hospital."

I also agree with the person who praised Stanley Tucci as Richard Cross. Tucci obviously reveled in playing scheming manipulative Mr. Cross and it's one of this brilliant actor's finest moments. The scene where Richard Cross flips his wig on the witness stand and propositions the female D.A and the female judge for three way sex is a classic. Tucci had the perfect condescending sneer and he oozed with the reptilian charm of a sociopath. In 1997 Tucci won three different industry awards for best television actor for his Richard Cross role.

Comments on other supporting actors: The dazzling talents of Patricia Clarkson were underused in her role as Ted Hoffman's wife. I think she would have been far better cast as either the D.A. or Ted's second chair litigator in for the trial. Barbara Bossom's matronly portrayal of Miriam Grasso was an annoying attempt to add an element of homespun likability to the ranking LA county prosecutor. It was a completely contrived and inauthentic portrayal of a prosecutor, especially in glam, image conscious world of the L.A. legal community.

Mary McCormack's portrayal of Justine Appleton character was well presented and my own ambivalence about the Appleton character has more to do with the way the part was written. Justine Appleton is a sweet fresh faced but highly ambitious attorney for the firm who gets corrupted by Richard Cross' campaign to add her to his collection of business aides. The subtext was innocent babes in the woods should be less ambitious or else they'll be seduced and corrupted by big bad wolfs, like Richard Cross.

At first, Dylan Baker seemed a steely and aloof as Detective Arthur Polson, but he does an amazing job of transforming Polson into a sympathetic character when investigates the kidnapping of Ted Hoffman's daughter.

A bit of context on "Murder One." The first episode of the show ran on television on September 19, 1995, two weeks before the verdict in O.J. Simpson trial, which had been going on nearly the entire summer of that year. Like the Simpson trial, the basic plot of "Murder One" involved trial of a brutal murder of a young woman by a high profile celebrity and was set in L.A.'s Parker Center. I've often wondered if Bochco got the idea for "Murder One" from the Simpson trial. It would be a real case of art imitating life.

It's been 16 years since the debut of "Murder One" and my suggestion is that anyone who liked the network run of the show should purchase the Season One DVD. I recently watched the entire season on DVD and it's every bit as entertaining even though some of the women's hairdos are the scariest part of the show. I had forgotten most of the details of the story line over the years, so it all seemed new to me. In fact "Murder One" was even better the second time around because back in 1995 I was in grad school and missed a few episodes so I was always trying to catch up with the story line.

reply

Hello mforum1,

I'm glad that someone other than me saw the parallel between the O.J. Simpson/Neil Avedon trials.
While I might be pilloried by other posters, I never believed that O.J. murdered his ex and Ron Goldman, and I was as happy at his acquittal as I was at Neil's.

reply

I didn't watch it when it aired, but I remember being confused by the change of the lead character. That was weird.

reply

The answer why Daniel Benzali left the show is revealed in Steven Bochco's autobiography Truth is a total defense: My 50 years in Television.

Basically Benzali was costing the production $$$$$'s a week in delays due to personal habits (I could tell you what they were but you wouldn't believe me). Bochco tried to reason with Benzali who wouldn't compromise so Bochco fired him after season 1.

It's a shame because Benzali is a great actor and from what I've read the show suffered after his character was written out but I completely agree with Bochco firing him. Bochco's autobiography is a great book, I highly recommend by the way.

reply

Bochco fired one of his lead actors over his 'morning dump'

https://www.datalounge.com/thread/21720438-bochco-fired-one-of-his-lead-actors-over-his-morning-dump-habits

When dropping off the kids at the pool makes you an hour late for work — you're out of a job.


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5997441/Steven-Bochco-fired-Daniel-Benzali-Murder-One-morning-dumps.html

reply