MovieChat Forums > Quigley Down Under (1990) Discussion > I love this movie, but one thing always ...

I love this movie, but one thing always bugs me...


The scene at the end when the Marshall and the Cavalry ride in and read him the warrant, and then all the Aborigines show up on the rim and the English all back down and ride away.... Who else thinks that entire scene was a complete waste of time, and could easily have been Edited out. They could have cut the film as the Elder Aborigine removes his shirt and walks off of Marston's Station, to the scene where Quigley and Cora meet up at the Shipping Docks.

reply

Yeah, I guess. One could argue that this Aborigines army was going to come and kick ass because of the cliff incident and Quigley doing what he did saved lives. Many would've been killed storming the ranch.

reply

Somebody must have heard you because when this movie is on "regular" TV, that entire scene is removed. It went from the last shootout to Quigley buying his ticket.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
"Let's not ask for the moon, we have the stars".

reply

I think that the scene is left in the movie as a means to have Quigley, an American, stick to the Brits again, as well as to add to the mythology of the Aboriginals and the fact that Quigley had become highly regarded by them.

My name is Gladiator - Maximus Decimus Meridius

reply

If it was TV, the scene was probably removed just to show more commercials.

reply

Throughout the movie they make mention to aborigine "magic" and mention that Quigley is known to them as "The Spirit Warrior," indicating that they believe in a form of magic and, since this a movie, perhaps utilize a bit of it in saving their savior. Now, that being said, Australia is such a weird continent that it is also entirely possible that they just hid in the brush and popped up when they were needed then disappeared into the dust storm that followed. I was more surprised by the fact that the british soldiers, with horses and guns, were worried about a bunch of aborigines with sticks. I am glad Quigley lived, but I still think it would have been more plausible for them to kill Quigley and then exterminate the aborigines and ride home - at least, that's britain's M.O.

reply

The sheer numbers of the aborigines would have overwhelmed the Brits, especially armed as they were with single-shot carbines, fired by cavalrymen whose marksmanship skills were neither encouraged or drilled very often.

No question that there might be a lot of dead aborigines after a full-blown attack, but I have no doubt of the result. It's not even likely that the standard ammunition issue to cavalrymen would be enough to repel such an attack.

Firepower and discipline are important, but as the Brits found out more than once, if you have greatly inferior numbers, such as in some of their African adventures, even an disciplined army is likely to be crushed by an overwhelming number of "primitive" warriors.

reply

They set up the Major as villainous in the beginning and then set up the Aborigines as allies to Quigby. To not have that pay off is a waste of time.

reply

It shows the respect and honor that the Aborigine's had for Mathew Quigley. He saved their lives and they saved his. I personally thought this was a key scene in the movie.

reply

I'm sure the Major was hardly a leader of men on the level of Robert E. Lee or George S. Patton. If he'd ordered his men to execute Quigley, they'd probably have acted very reluctantly. Sometimes I think the British Empire existed in spite of itself...for every Chard or Gordon there was a Cardigan or Raglan...

reply

The major was in Marston's pocket. That was established early in the film.

reply

I'm thinking it was mostly for a dramatic effect, and maybe to add a few more minutes to the films length...

But you have to admit, the scene does have a really nice surreal touch to it...magical even...

reply

He saved them, then they repaid the favor. I think it's an essential part of the movie and hate that the TV versions cut it for commercial space.

reply