MovieChat Forums > The Woman in Black (1989) Discussion > is the bed scene really that terrifying?

is the bed scene really that terrifying?


opinions?

reply

No, maybe because I had anticipated it so much & was expecting something better but personally I thought it wasn't even vaguely scary. That didn't detract from the over all creepy brilliance of the film though.

Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is no path and leave a trail-R.W Emerson

reply

It gave me goosebumps, and let's just say I'm in no real hurry to see it again.

reply

I've never found it to be that scary. Scariest scenes for me:

1) When Kipp sees her in the cemetery outside of the utility shed at Eel Marsh House.

2) When Kipp goes into the nursery.

reply

It's scary if you're 10. It had me screaming and traumatized when I was 8, and I was afraid to watch it when I found the film again at 20.

However, once I did I laughed at myself. Her face looks completely human and very disappointing. Even her makeup sucks. They should have made her paler, older and more dead looking. She just looks like any other woman just with bigger eye bulbs.

reply



It's not scary at all. And I didnt know she was going to appear suddenly.

reply

[deleted]

I'll agree with this. It scared me when she first appeared, but by the end of the scene it seemed overdone.


A laugh can be a very powerful thing. Why, sometimes in life, it's the only weapon we have.

reply

If you don't know it's there, and don't think about it too much - hell yes!

A lot of emphasis is put on that scene on these message boards. But that's not what the film is about. It builds the tension up wonderfully, for her inevitable appearance in the conclusion.

reply

No, not really. But it depends on what scares you. It didn't scare me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRpBdYgh4cA

Bless your face. If you sneezed while reading this comment, bless you. Peace off.

reply

*SPOILERS*
I thought it was easily the scariest bit of the whole thing. It's so well done: Kidd looking up in horror as this massive shadow arises before him and then THAT face being unrelentingly forced on the viewer for far longer than most "shock" moments on film. You get such a sense of her overwhelming rage and hatred - I practically fell off my chair!

Impaled on my Nobel Peace Prize- how ironic.

reply

The builld-up to that scene is intensly scary, brilliantly done. However, I think they did a mistake in changing her appearance, she should have looked like in the other scenes. As it is, she looks like a halloween witch.
I find the scenes by the cemetaries and the nursery far more frightening.

*******
They're coming for you, Barbara!

My blog(Norwegian):
http://jennukka.wordpress.com

reply

Like someone mentioned here before, I think the scene is very effective. However, I just think it's a little too long, agree? The first shot of her above him in the bed are stunning, but I think it all could do better without that close-up that follows, if I remember it right.

The unexpected and sudden is basically the key ingredient in delivering shock, and to this day, this scene could be one of the best shock-inducing scenes of all time.

/ Daniel (Sweden)

reply

When you're 10? years old at the time, yes, it is scary, heh

But by todays standards, not so much.

reply