MovieChat Forums > Spoorloos (1988) Discussion > Films like this show exactly the differe...

Films like this show exactly the difference between foreign filmmaking and American filmmaking...


In my years of watching movies from abroad, I have noticed that films by those outside the US are more willing to go places that American mainstream audiences shy away from and this film and the American re-make illustrate that.

We Americans tend to appreciate more positive movies or movies with clear endings than other countries.

I'm not suggesting that American filmmakers NEVER go to the dark side, but that in comparison to other countries, filmmakers abroad seem more comfortable telling stories of discomfort than American audiences like to view (though I do think with the increased use of streaming, American filmmakers are trending more and more to provocative films and programs).

reply


Yes.

American mainstream audiences 'just want to be entertained' and then they want to go away from a movie feeling that everything is alright again with the world. They resist ambiguity. They don't want complexity or anything particularly challenging. They're not terribly keen on having to interpret things for themselves. (Not that they can't, of course, they just don't think they should have to.)

And they don't take too kindly to downbeat endings.

I suppose it all goes back to the 'golden age' of Hollywood and its escapist fantasies and factory-style mass entertainment filmmaking. And the production code. All of that has just built in certain traditions and cultural expectations of films that other nations don't really share -- continuing to have smaller budgets that allow filmmaking to be treated more like an art than a commodity.

But, of course, it's worth pointing out that, A) the USA is one of the largest markets for international cinema in the world, so this certainly doesn't apply to all American audiences by any stretch of the imagination, and that B) American mainstream films are popular throughout most of the globe, so it's not as though those of us in different nations firmly reject that stuff.

But you're absolutely right that this is the tendency... although, of course, with American indie films and things with smaller budgets it's far less the tendency because they can afford to appeal only to a niche audience, and that part of the US film industry has more in common with filmmaking elsewhere in the world.

reply

Such a wonderful reply. Thank you. Wish there were so much more of this at MC.

I just started really getting into streaming back in 2018 and it is utterly amazing at the amount of content available worldwide when it comes to programs and movies (I chuckle when I hear someone suggest there is nothing on the television).

I've followed movies about all my adult life and it is so interesting when it comes to the layers of entertainment worldwide. Heck, one could spend a lifetime just "catching up" on programs never seen before (one frustrating thing is when you watch one of the older programs that were anticipating a second season but didn't get it without knowing the program had been canceled before everything could be resolved).

Another thing I've noticed about American viewers is many of them do not fully understand the layers involved when it comes to American productions entering the world market, especially when it comes to film editing when content included may offend citizens of a different country.

Best wishes....

reply