The South nowadays


I saw this movie a second time, right after "A Time to Kill", and a documentary about the KKK, but it made me wonder, how is the South right now?

I'm from Europe (and progressive left-wing and all you want), and seeing this, it's sort of unreal, but it isn't new. The South of the USA is always represented that way (thank you Hollywood and the CNN), but I wonder - in 2010 - howmuch of that is still true? I mean, you could argue that still most of the south vote republic (though usually cities tend to be more democratic), but I don't think voting right-wing makes you a short-sighted racist.

So how does the south look in 2010? Are all Americans living peacefully next to each other, or do some towns still make a distinction between colour? are there still separated toilets? do they think some fellow Americans don't wash?

I studied about fear for unknown things, but I figure the South's also living in 2010.

reply

I live in Alaska, but have lived in the South (I don't include Texas, unless it's the eastern half). Lived In Shreveport, Louisiana for 7 years of my life that I'll never get back. Their idea of "progress" is building a bunch of casinos. As for racism, I'll put it this way. Even though it was 20 years ago, a man named David Duke was running for governor. This slimebag was a Grand Wizard of the KKK and some Uncle Tom was on TV defending him when he was running. Nearly half the state voted for him and over 35% of Louisiana is black. Do the math. Anyway, his headqurters in neighboring Bossier City had 2 vehicles parked in front of it to include a BMW and a truck with a Confederate Flag license plate and a shotgun hooked to the back window.

So, to answer your question, I think racism in the south is still very alive and well, but covert. Many generations of inbreeding have destroyed the minds of those Crackers, so I cut them a little slack.

reply

[deleted]

Sounds like the intolerance is all your own.

reply

[deleted]

"Many generations of inbreeding have destroyed the minds of those Crackers, so I cut them a little slack."

I find it both humorous and weird that the south gets accused with inbreeding. In the south (I'm from Tennessee and currently live in Georgia) that what we say about people from New Jersey!

reply

The difference is that southerners really are stupid inbreds who talk funny.

reply

I'm from Ellisville, Mississippi. I had the good fortune to be an extra in Mississippi Burning. I even worked directly (albeit briefly) with Michael Rooker for several takes of one scene. A very rare thing to happen to any extra in a major production. Alan Parker was an okay guy. Very no-nonsense.

As for my bieng a "stupid inbred", well--I haven't studied my ancestry that closely. (FWIW, I've read that inbreeding is much more frequent in poor urban areas *outside* the South.) But I did go on to earn a Bachelor of Science in microbiology, 3.2 GPA.

A fluke? Maybe. But my late father was a self-taught engineer who grew up dirt-poor in Depression-era Mississippi. He went on to become the vice-president of a major east coast utility, before moving on to general manager of Consolidated Edison's gas operations for all of New York City. His management acumen was such that the Board of Directors wanted to make him president of ConEd. (For reasons still unclear, Dad wouldn't take the job.)

He almost didn't make it out of the South. In his teen years he was perceived as being a bit too chummy with the local black folk, and two brothers from a hostile family went gunning for him. He mananged to avoid them until he was called up by the local draft board in '43.

Now, what does all that prove? Not much--except there's perhaps a hell of a lot about the South of which you don't know jack.

reply

problem is, tards like you see 'racism' in everything.

reply

If you think that then maybe you are a part of the problem.

------------------------------
Prepare to be judged....with a FGM-148 Javelin!

reply

I just fucking hate smug pieces of elitist shit like you.

reply

I think the South is better on race than it has been in the past. What is interesting is that in College or Pro sports teams in the South the majority of players are black and the majority of fans in the stands are white. It is interesting to see this in colleges across the South since integration in the 1960s and 1970s. The University of Mississippi has really tried to make amends for the mistakes of the past.

To understand were the South is now though you have to understand the politics of the past that have shaped it. I would highly recommend reading 'Revolt of the Rednecks Mississippi Politics, 1876-1925' by Albert D. Kirwan and 'The Earl of Louisiana' by A. J. Liebling. These books really show what terrible positions certain politicians used to become elected in the South.

I would also recommend 'Confederates in the Attic' by Tony Horwitz which is a good look at American Civil War remembrance in the '90s and present day race relations in the South. It is a sometimes flawed but overall very fascinating book.

As Randy Newman put it in his great song 'Rednecks' the race problem has not only been a huge Southern problem but a national problem. I think the whole United States needs to continue to work on this as it has over the last fifty years.

Here is Newman's performance of that song that captures the irony of race relations in the United States so well:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2nGw_vAnqPI

It has only been a short time really since all of these events have taken place and I believe that things can continue to improve in the South. The South has tried to make belated amends in the prosecution of crimes that took place in the Civil Rights era. I think race relations can continue to get better in the South.

I would recommend seeing the documentary 'Prom Night in Mississippi' with Morgan Freeman showing some of the race relations of the present day. I think it would answer quite a few of your questions.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1334555/

Frank: Just a man.
Harmonica: An ancient race.

reply

Does a current-day series like "True Blood" reflect race relations as they are today in the South more accurately?

reply

No, not even close. Racism has improved so much that our country is now focusing on “micro aggressions” and we often see “hoax hate crimes” now. Yes, not a week or so goes by where we see another black person stage a hate crime. You never saw these staged hate crimes in the 60s! You know why? It’s because there was enough brutal racism as is

reply

Majority black athletes playing in front of predominantly white fans at college football games in the south today is really no different than the days when performers like Cab Calloway, Chuck Berry or Little Richard sang onstage to all-white, segregated audiences.

reply

I also thought this was a poor argument. It only means that they realised they had to let the blacks play who are far superior than them in those sports to win a title (which in turn brings money?).. not that the black people are overall accepted.

reply

"Majority black athletes playing in front of predominantly white fans at college football games in the south today is really no different than the days when performers like Cab Calloway, Chuck Berry or Little Richard sang onstage to all-white, segregated audiences."

I'm going to have to throw the Bullshe-it flag on this comment. There are people of all races in the stands watching the games too.

reply

Although it would be optimistic to assume things have changed down there, I would not be surprised if there were little places just like Jessop County still living this segregated lifestyle even today.

Some things will never change.

reply

I'm not too sure about Alabama however.

reply


Perhaps some of you should travel more and quit watching STUPID movies like this one and " A Time to Kill".
nullo facere opinari omnia in serium convertere. vitae ad eundem modum jocari

reply

Why is the movie stupid? There are rascistsall over the world, and people hate each other because of their color of their skin, and THAT IS stupid, NOT the movie, but hey, maybe you are a rascist? Jusk asking...

reply

It is stupid in its broad depiction of ALL white Southerners as inbreed murderers. It's racist for depicting black Americans as being docile.


nullo facere opinari omnia in serium convertere. vitae ad eundem modum jocari

reply

Hey, speak in English pal! Don`t hide your feeling behind latin text.

reply

And, if this movie is so stupid (it is NOT), why are you wasting your time looking it up on the Database??? One would think you wouldn't give it a second thought, but here you are...

reply

While I'm from the North, I just want to clarify something. The KKK was mostly made up of conservative Democrats. When the KKK held lots of power over elections, they repeatedly tried to get Republicans out of power or stop them from running, sometimes even using violence.

The way the country votes now is completely flipped from it was back then. During the time period of this movie, the south voted primarily Democrat and the North voted Republican while today, it is the opposite. Also remember that Abe Lincoln was a republican. ;)

I know you aren't saying that Republicans=racists, but there is a tendency for people to think that when it's really the farthest thing from the truth when you look at history.

reply

That is true, but you have to remember that the ideologies of Democrats and the Republicans were the complete opposite of what they are today.

The Democrats were conservative. The Republicans were the party that held the progressive views. This started to change after the end of WW2. The fact that the South originally voted Democrat in large numbers therefore does not indicate that the region was especially liberal, and the shift towards a Republican majority does not indicate a swing in political opinion.

Not an attack, just something to take into consideration. Of course, what I have written is a very brief summary of the whole process, and I do not pretend to be an expert on the matter. If you want to know more about I'm sure there is a wealth of historical writing about it.

Cheers

"You're only supposed to blow the bloody doors off"

reply

racism is bull**** lazy stubborn depressed people angry at everything blaming everyone else for their boring basement lifestyle, black men fought hard during ww2 to ensure we live the way we do now, if they're good enough to die for our survival, they're damned deserved our respect, it's just a shame that it still happens.

as for true blood, I'd say yes and no, primarily beacause anyone can be racist, it's only words, and *beep* don't care who they offend, but also beacause TB is designed to emphasise that southern stereotypically racist redneck anyways.

reply

Hmmm... I am just rewatching the movie now.


A couple of things from my subjective point of view.

I consider it a vital personal freedom that everyone is allowed their oppinions. That includes the right to be stupid and ie. smoke and even the right to be racist.

If you are white and want to avoid blacks or vice versa (or whatever completely irrelevant generalising line people want to draw), they do have that right.

However the right to be of any oppinion should never extent as far to give right to break the law, hurt other people OR infringe on other peoples right to seek their own way in life.

To sum up... People have a right to be dumb, but no right to take away others rights.

Personally? I think that, even if you do hate, hate itself is a terrible waste of time and energy. And rather unconstructive for oneself or others.

reply

The irony is the Republican party was founded on an abolitionist platform. The Democratic party was the party of Jim Crow laws, the Klan, etc.

reply

Yeah... Lincoln wouldn't recognize the Republican party as it is today. Like another user said, the parties have just changed names, up to 100 years ago or so. So, the north/south votes haven't changed just the name of the parties.

reply

The south has always been mostly conservative and the north mostly progressive but it was about 1924 during the political reform that the parties names changed. Lincoln was a republican but he wouldn't recognize the party today. He would be a registered Democrat in today's political climate.

So, basically the KKK has always been conservative and was known as a democratic party until the reform and is now republican in name but has always had the same conservative political views.

Please do research before posting a bunch of unintelligent *beep* on imdb.

reply

I live in the South now, and let me clear some things up. There are *a lot* of racist douches. There are *a lot* of homophobic douches (of many races, how they can live with themselves I do not know). There's a lot of stupidity and uneducated people. However, like with anywhere, this is not how all people are. It's not even how the majority is, especially the younger generation. While many of the younger generation turn out just like their racist homophobic hateful parents, often in the name of "tradition", so many more are going against them, learning about tolerance and educating themselves. I think a big part of this is the internet, where they're forced to be exposed to things they otherwise would only have locals and family to influence them with.

I'm not saying it's perfect, but the majority of the south is most certainly not like the bigotry displayed in this movie. And it seems lately you can find bigotry all over, just look at California, supposedly one of the most progressive states ever, and Proposition 8. We, the human race, have a long long way to go, sadly, and there is still a hatred of things that deserve no hatred. Hopefully the more we are open and tolerant of one another (no more "cracker", no more *beep* no more *beep* no more "fag", or any other racist term) the more we'll make progress.

ETA: Interesting that cracker and fag are not censored, whereas n | gg er and sp | c are. I do not like any of these words, and used them merely as examples, but once again it goes to prove how far we have to go before all people are equal.

WALLEForum.com

reply

With me living in Georgia, I would have to say that's it's not like the movie depicts. I've lived down here for a while and I've run into a fair share of racists, but the southern folks generally don't care if their neighbor is black, white or of another race. You will find more racism in older folks than you will the younger people.

reply

Cracker and fag aren't censored because they have significant non slur meanings.

reply

True. Crackers are often eaten with cheese and in the U.K. a fag is a cigarette.

reply

Who's racist? In the 2008 elections, white Americans closely split their votes ( 55%-43%)McCain-Obama, but African Americans voted for "one of their own" 96% of the time.
There is a paradigm among fans of this film that only white Americans can be racist.

Also I reiterate my point, TRAVEL !!! Go places and meet people.
Many of you are very prejudiced against the Southeastern USA and judging a state based on this ignorant lowbrow of a film simply feeds your prejudices.


nullo facere opinari omnia in serium convertere. vitae ad eundem modum jocari

reply

Well, I grew up in Raymond, MS., just down the road from the house used as Mayor Tilman's was filmed. I grew up in this small town, outside of Jackson, from 1973-1992. I never was aware of any racism growing up. We all grew up together and went to the same schools. I remember in high school, we had a 30 minute break after second period. The students all milled about in the hallways and some class rooms. We didn't really have cliques. Sure white kids would tend to get together as well as the blacks. However, I don't recall any instances of anyone being shunned. If there were, it was usually because a person just wasn't liked by another or whatever, like typical teenagers.

Looking back, I recall the only doctor's office in town. You would walk in the front door and there was a waiting room to the left and another to the right. For some reason, the whites usually went left and the blacks went right. I don't recall any instructions as to which was which by my parents or the staff. As far as I know, it just was. I do recall some folks going to either side. The waiting area to the left was the access to the exam rooms in the back, so everybody had to go through there and would have to go there to sign in at the window.

Another thing was a large private pool just outside of downtown (as it were). I suppose you could say that it was a club because they charged an annual membership, but also had a daily rate of a dollar or so. They used to have baseball games and Fourth of July parties there when I was little, but not much in the later years. I can't say that I recall seeing any blacks there, but I can't say that there never were. I wouldn't say that it was based on racism as many whites wouldn't be able to go either. But, I never knew if there was any reason for the membership other than chemicals and upkeep.

All in all, I won't say that there weren't any racists in town. I knew of some kids who would say un-polite things or jokes in certain company, but they were very few. Of course there's the possibility that I was too young and was oblivious to it. My folks were protective, but I don't think they would have shielded me from anything, especially in my teen years. If it was there, for some reason or another, I never saw it.

BTW, someone was mentioning books to read. I recommend the Politically Incorrect Guide to the South (and Why It Will Rise Again) by Clint Johnson. In it, he highlights many of the great things of the South and how many are bent continuing the many myths about it. You also start to discover that the racism wasn't as widespread and slavery wasn't as bad as we're taught. It's similar to the Old West. When you really look into it and study it, it wasn't was wild and violent as TV, movies, books etc. make it out to be. NOTE: I am NOT saying that racism doesn't exist and that slavery wasn't a bad institution. I'm merely offering that it wasn't what we're told to believe.

reply