MovieChat Forums > The Witches of Eastwick (1987) Discussion > Cher vs Susan vs Michelle : which one do...

Cher vs Susan vs Michelle : which one do you prefer ?


They're all fantastic and beautiful actresses but I've always had a soft spot(and i'm a girl) for Michelle.Anyway,they're all breathtakingly stunning : the wise brunette,the shy red-haired and the dreamy blonde.







OSCARS 2010 : COLIN FIRTH/MELANIE LAURENT/ CHRISTOPH WALTZ/MO'NIQUE

reply

I would definitely have to say Michelle Pfeiffer. She's so beautiful (and I still believe she would have been awesome as Galadriel on LOTR). I think Cher is very pretty too but I never really found Susan Sarandon to be very attractive. I hate turtle eyes.

**********
In Stranger Eons

reply

[deleted]

Cher !!!!

reply

Definitely Cher in this movie but i do like Michelle. I like them all but I think Susan Sarandon looked weird in this film. Susan really didn't do it for me in this one. So it's between Cher and Michelle. I think Cher suited my mind set for this movie better.

So Cher for Witches of Eastwick.
But I love Michelle in What Lies Beneath!!
I haven't seen many films with Susan Sarandon in them. Bull Durham but I can't really stand sports films or sports video games. It's like some kind of allergy I've got. I just instantly go ughhhh sports film.....cannnt watttch.... channngee channelll....


She did look good in Bull Durham though! Well from what i could tell, fast forwarding to the good bits....years ago as a teen. :P

reply

I don't get the Sarandon thing: can't decide if she's homely or pretty. If you notice her arms while playing tennis, she's already literally sagging, and this was many years ago. So, I don't see how Sarsndon is "hot". On many actresses' boards, they are calling an 80 yr old "hot". Ok.

Michelle has always has a beautiful face which can't be denied; don't know about her body.
And of course,Cher fans will always prefer her, as a relex, for the sake of being Cher.

reply

Michelle has always has a beautiful face which can't be denied; don't know about her body.
_________________

Have you seen her in BATMAN RETURNS as Catwoman? Her body is fully covered in a shiny vinyl suit; but she is slinky, sexy and just plain terrific all over in this....IMHO.
_______
I don't get the Sarandon thing: can't decide if she's homely or pretty.

_________________
Found Sarandon had her own specialness when she was around in the 70's, 80's and early 90's. She wasn't a traditional beauty or overtly pretty, but I found she had her own unique gorgeousness with those expressive and sultry eyes. She did start to age and mature a bit looks wise come the early 90's and 'WITCHES...', was probably the start of this. Have always gravitated towards some unusual quality in Sarandon for some reason—both in looks and performance wise—can't quite seem to put my finger on it though. Some of it could be nostalgia and some of it could just be her own character and personality shining through. I was over the moon when she won her oscar® for DEAD MAN WALKING.

reply

Well spoken,rascal67.
More power to you!


=========================
badgers? badgers!? WE DON'T NEED NO STINKIN' BADGERS!!!

reply

As I grow older I find myself attracted to intelligent women,more than their physical appearance.
Susan,although I don't always need to hear her political speeches,is still beautiful.
She's a gilf! She has the full package.
And I've always loved her big,beautiful..
eyes

=========================
badgers? badgers!? WE DON'T NEED NO STINKIN' BADGERS!!!

reply

Susan Sarandon was the three B's - built, beautiful and bad. You can throw in two more B's. She was also brainy and bi (maybe). The witches being bisexual was hinted at. Sarandon was hotter than hell.

Cher has an interesting look. She has always been attractive.

Michelle Pfeiffer is so skinny she has only one side. Is she anorexic? Skinny girls don't do it for me. Cher has always been thin. Pfeiffer is skinny. There is a difference.

reply

Sarandon, was the one who grabbed my attention the most. Cher has a strong presence, but don't find her particularly sexy or beautiful, just unusual—albeit a tad freaky looking. Pfeiffer's was lovely, but a bit bland in this.

reply

[deleted]

If I had to pick one right off the bat? Easy. Michelle.

reply

[deleted]

For this film I think Susan Sarandon did the best job of acting which is incredible since she was told just a couple of days before filming that she would no longer be playing Alex but Jane. She still managed to steal the film.

But my favorite actress of all three and the most beautiful imo is Michelle Pfeiffer.

reply