MovieChat Forums > Na srebrnym globie (1989) Discussion > Why did anyone give this movie a 10?

Why did anyone give this movie a 10?


If you gave the film a rating of nine or ten why did you do so? I would like to understand how you judge a film. I scored this one on the opposite pole and would like to know your reasoning. This is one of the worst films I have ever seen.

reply

I gave it an 8/10. It's ambitious, imaginative, fascinating and flawed. The first hour of the film is actually pretty damn brilliant and the images, costumes and camerawork is excellent throughout. There's a bit too much dialogue for my liking and the constant shouting from Mark did start to annoy me after a little while but apart from that, and a some minor niggles (the new footage used to fill in the gaps could've been more creative) I really enjoyed this film.

Cinema is the memory of life.

reply

Hey, guys, but doesn't it kinda annoy you, that none of the characters' dialogue make any sense? I don't mind ambitious, deep and ambiguous flicks, but come on! At least speak proper Polish!

reply

The dialogues didnĀ“t make any sense for me too, I was very bored but it was a great experience anyway.

reply

Not bad - 7.5

"She let me go."
~White Oleander

reply