MovieChat Forums > Flowers in the Attic (1987) Discussion > One Moment Early In the Film That Muddle...

One Moment Early In the Film That Muddles the Plot...


...Comes when the father (Marshall Colt) gives Cathy (Kristy Swanson) the music/jewelry box and the camera moves over to the door frame and we see Mom (Victoria Tennant) gazing with an icy intensity at this tender moment between father and daughter.

Jealousy? It sure looks like it, but if it is, they never bother to develop it; the scene has no foreshadowing and nothing is made of it later on so I can't help thinking they forgot to chop it out in the editing process. It would certainly add a bunch of questions for the viewer: for starters, did Mom tamper with the brakes in Dad's car? Was this a plot of her making from the beginning?

The answer in all the novels is "No;" Corinne and Christopher are a couple very much in love despite their near-blood connection.

Should have taken that shot out of the scene; it adds nothing except a lot of irrelevant questions.



Oh God. There's nothing more inconvenient than an old queen with a head cold!

reply

It is kind of foreshadowing, though. It is to show that Corrine and Cathy do not have the smoothest relationship (hence later: "Always, it's you!" then slap...and slap) That moment later does not come as a surprise because right from the beginning (this particular scene followed sporadically by a few others) it is demonstrated that Corrine has always had issues with Cathy. Cathy and her father were closer. The voice over in that scene says how "he never let me forget that I was his favorite." Simultaneously, Corrine was always closer with Christopher. So, if she were to watch Chris Sr. and Jr. together, she would probably be beaming with joy. However, this scene with that little moment is to have many layers demonstrating to the audience that something is a little off. It shows that (and is explained later) that Corrine has a little bit of a dark side...and in particular, a resentment against her daughter, Cathy. The audience is supposed to wonder for a moment what it is about in that moment to put them slightly on guard. Yet, it dissolves into a (brief) happier moment in order to have the audience think back on it later. It becomes an opportunity to suggest that because Cathy is closer to her father, there is already a dividing wall between her and her mother. At this time in their lives, it is not crucial but it definitely contributes to what happen later on. There are lots of little moments in the film where Corrine is looking off into space or focused on something that makes the audience wonder what exactly is she thinking. She isn't as great as she pretends to be.

reply

Also, the scene repeats with different players later. Corrine is reading to her father. He touches her similar to the way Chris Sr. touched Cathy. And the grandmother looks on, the same way.

It seems that father/daughter relationships in that family were always "off".

I don't really think that Cathy and her mother always had problems though. In the beginning, she narrates that she had wanted to be "just like her mother" when she was younger.

reply

I agree with you. Cathy’s hate for her mom developes later while she’s locked up. If you read the whole series it explains how this hate followed her outside the Attic.

reply