MovieChat Forums > Heartbreak Ridge (1986) Discussion > Why would a women be showering during a ...

Why would a women be showering during a hostage situation.


Clearly it was just for the nudity.

reply

Yeah this scene made absolutely no sense. I don't think it was necessary. If they wanted to make this scene mean anything then they should have had a Cuban soldier about to go in the shower and then Jones shoots him and rescue the chick.

reply

Although I am a female I will say this. Females can be downright stupid during emergency situations. We have regular fire alarms on the dorms (I am the dorm mother) and thankfully they have all been false alarms. Just try to get those girls out of the shower and out of their rooms in less than 5 minutes. The security tell us to just wait till there is a real fire and watch them run when they have flames licking at their backsides. They sure ran when that 7.2 quake hit in AZ back in early April. We are in San Diego but they got the heck out of the dorms in a hurry. The swing dorm mother made them all go back outside again when they got back inside the dorm last week and do it all over again till they get it right and got out in a timely manner.Hate to say it guys but the boys can be just as stupid and stubborn. We have male dorms here also.

reply

The stupidity isn't depending on gender, it's because those're kids.

"Oh no, what if [insert name of guy/girl they have the hots for] saw me without makeup on, I better apply some mascara before I get out of the burning collapsing zombie-invaded building"

Light travels faster than sound,
that's why people seem bright,
until you hear them.

reply

the students didnt know they were in any danger to begin with., they were surpised when the marines showed up.

reply

the students DID know they were in danger. they knew there was a 24 hr curfew that had been in place for a couple of days. they were told that they would be shot on sight if they were caught outside their dorms. some may have been surprised when the Rangers, (the Marines didn't free any students), showed up because they may not have gotten the word that an invasion was taking place. and by the way, i was there during the invasion.

reply

Well, they're not exactly kids. Med students are at least 22, 23.




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

BTW: The students I am writing about in this are between 16 and 25 so it isn't just gender that can be stupid. The students in this movie are pretty much the same age.

reply

I worked with a GySgt that participated in the Grenada operation, and he said the toilets at the college were clogged from the students flushing their drugs because they thought the Marines were doing a drug raid on the island.

reply

You got something against gratuitous nudity? What are ya, one of them commies?

reply

Don't look a gifthorse in the mouth. We don't question the gratuitous female nudity, we just sit back and enjoy it.

I don't have an opinion. The word "opinion" implies the possibility I'm wrong.

reply

'Cause boobs are awesome.

reply

Because you can't have a manly military movie without some titties thrown in.

reply

There is another theory. At the beginning of the movie, how would Jones have reacted to seeing a hot naked girl? At the end, he merely says "United States Marines." Perhaps that's what they were going for.

---
"24 hours a day, 7 days a week. No job is too big. No fee is too big!", Ghostbusters

reply

It wasn't a hostage situation yet. The OpFor were nearing the school, but weren't there yet.

reply

the students didnt know they were in any danger to begin with., they were surpised when the marines showed up.


They obviously knew they were in danger. They were all gathered inside a crowded room and jumped up in joy when the marines showed up.

reply

Some people can be really stubborn and set in their ways and will insist on trying to continue with their normal routine even though it’s no longer possible or sensible.

I work in security risk management and the stupid stuff people do is amazing.

I do agree though it was just for the nudity. It’s also possible that she was shagging the hostage takers in exchange for comforts. That also happens I can’t recall how long they were held hostage for though.

reply