MovieChat Forums > The Emerald Forest (1985) Discussion > Good rainforest movie marred by eye-roll...

Good rainforest movie marred by eye-rolling bits and tacked on eco message


This is similar to the earlier “A Man Called Horse” story-wise, albeit involving a teen plus featuring the Amazon setting of “Fitzcarraldo." It influenced later movies like “Dances With Wolves” and, as far as ‘look’ goes, “Apocalypto." Being helmed by John Boorman, it’s a quality production.

Unfortunately, this is the least of these movies and therefore justifiably obscure. It’s not only the unnecessary environmental message in the second half but, worse, the laughable implication concerning a rain dance. (Why Sure!)

Isn't it ironic how “Natives” in the Americas are now adorned with god-like powers and sage-like stature in cinema? (I put ‘Natives’ in quotations because they’re actually the progeny of settlers from Asia via Beringia). If these Amazonian Indians had that much power, then taking care of the technologically advanced encroachers or enemy tribes would be a piece of cake.

Another criticism is the unrealistic portrayal of The Invisible People. It’s way too paradisal with too little emphasis on the mundaneness and hardships inherent to such a life in the deep equatorial forest. For instance, the nubile females appear overly fresh and immaculate for living amidst gross jungle challenges. In other words, they seem like girls who’ve lived a relatively soft life with modern conveniences (I’ve seen the real-life articles/photos in National Geographic and they’re very different). Both “Apocalypto” and “At Play in the Fields of the Lord” offer a less fantastical portrayal.

The story was inspired by a supposedly true event, but the man who lost his son to a mysterious tribe was Peruvian, not American, not to mention he was a lumberjack rather than an engineer. It took sixteen years for him to find his son, who had been totally assimilated into the primitive culture. Responding to these deviations, it was said that the screenplay was based on several real-life stories, not just this one.

reply