MovieChat Forums > Sophie's Choice (1983) Discussion > What do Polish people here think of Mery...

What do Polish people here think of Meryl's accent?


So, I'm curious... to me, as an American, Meryl was totally convincing as a Polish person.

However... I understand that with most accents that are learned by actors, they're almost never going to sound authentic to the native speakers of those accents.

I'm actually taking dialect lessons right now to learn a Polish accent, and I'm really stressed out about getting it to sound authentic. Obviously, I'd love to do it as well as Meryl. But my dialect coach tells me that it's going to be a "Hollywood Polish accent," something that Americans can understand, and it's not necessarily going to sound good to native Polish people. He told me a story about how one time, years ago, he worked on a film where the actors had to speak with Scottish accents. The film was being filmed in Scotland, and the local Scots were saying, "That is NOT HOW WE TALK!" He told the producer about this, and the producer told him, "Originally, I was using REAL Scottish actors, but the thing was... nobody could understand what the hell they were saying!"

So... an accent can't be TOO PERFECT or else the audience won't be able to understand what the actor is saying.

So, for any Polish people reading this board... what did you guys think of Meryl's accent? Did it sound authentic, or did it sound like a "Hollywood Polish accent?"

reply

Re: the Scots and their accents that "nobody could understand what the hell they were saying!"
Did you know that when the film 'Trainspotting' was first released in England, it played with sub-titles so the English could understand what the Scots were saying?
LMAO!
BTW, I think Meryl is the best. She is a magic lady.

Love me, love my

reply

[deleted]

My father was born in the US, but his parents were from Poland and Polish was spoken in the home more than English when my father was a young child. As a result, he was fluent in Polish.

I remember when this movie first came out, my Dad said he was very impressed with Meryl's accent. He didn't say she was perfect, but he thought she was very good.

I know an earlier Polish poster didn't agree, but that's definately what my father thought.

Now, growing up around Polish speaking family, I have an ear for it even though I only can say a few phrases. I find I can always recognize Polish when I hear it spoken in the population, I always can differentiate it from other Slavic languages, Russian, Czech, Hungarian, etc. And to me, Sophie's Polish and her accent sounded not quite the same as my relatives' or other Polish I hear spoken. But of course, since I don't speak Polish, you can't really go by my opinion.

reply

Magyars are not Slavs. Hungarian is an Ugro-Finnic language:)

reply

You mean Fenno-Ugric... :)



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Same thing :)

reply

I am a native Polish speaker living in America and I would say that Meryl's accent is pretty damn good. Can't say the same for when she actually speaks Polish though. At certain times I couldn't understand her whatsoever, all the words churned together and sounded like gibberish. You could tell right away that she was not a native Polish speaker but her accent? She nailed it.

reply

Well with accents it's difficult considering that not every Polish person is going to sound the same speaking English, it all depends on how long they've lived in a country, how many languages they already know etc. I mean I'm from Iceland and you can 10 different people and ask them to speak English and I am sure all of them have different way of speaking it dialect wise. I know of few polish people and they all sound different speaking English, Sophie herself spoke German better than English, she spoke fluent Russian and other languages, it may be that she emphasised more on certain words and spoke them differently considering she was studying a new language while some Polish person who had lived in the country for years would different.

reply