MovieChat Forums > All That Jazz (1979) Discussion > Anyone Else think this film is very Kubr...

Anyone Else think this film is very Kubrickish with a Fosse twist?


I felt like that if Kubrick made a Musical this would be similar to how it turned out.























see you later

reply

Only a "Fosse twist"?

Nah, it feels like pure Fosse to me, though I will grant that "pure Fosse" has some points of similarity with some of Kubrick's work.

Still, in the body of work that includes Cabaret and Sweet Charity and the original stage version of Chicago and the "floating hands" dance and sexual openness of the original Pippin, etc. ........ I see All That Jazz as fitting right in.

reply

Well I'm more familiar with Kubrick than I am Fosse(in film) so that may be why I feel this way. I definitely see a Fosse story. I meant the directing mostly seemed very Kubrick-like to me.






















see you later

reply

Actually the movie comes across as if Fellini made a big musical. Basically the auto-biography nature mixing with real show biz life with a surreal touches is straight out of 8 1/2. (It is OK because Woody Allen and other film-makers did also. All That Jazz is better than Stardust Memories.)

reply

The only Kubrick film that plays similarly to "All That Jazz", at least to me, would be "A Clockwork Orange". What they share in common: roughly similar pacing; vivid colors; an (anti-) hero with great talent and unchecked libido.

reply

Agree on "Clockwork Orange", and also there's a bit of "Barry Lyndon" in there. It feels specifically like a Kubrick 70s film (as you say, the colors, pacing, editing).

Did I not love him, Cooch? MY OWN FLESH I DIDN'T LOVE BETTER!!! But he had to say 'Nooooooooo'

reply

Yes, Fellini used the circus as a metaphor for life. For Fosse the metaphor is the
Broadway musical.

reply

I was thinking that while I was watching it. And then there's a joke in the film about Kubrick..... so, hmmmm....

Did I not love him, Cooch? MY OWN FLESH I DIDN'T LOVE BETTER!!! But he had to say 'Nooooooooo'

reply

Yes, Gideon(Fosse) compared himself deprecatingly with Kubrick. Kubrick had a better
opinion of Fosse calling "All That Jazz" "a perfect film." And Kubrick like Fosse
was very much a perfectionist.

reply

I agree or can see how you would think this. In that I feel that Bob Fosse was, in making All That Jazz and also Cabaret, was very very close to being on par with Stanley Kubrick. Now if only he had had a scene were he followed someone down a very long hallway.

reply

But Kubrick, a former photographer, used really pretty visuals and cinematography. All That Jazz is one of the ugliest movies I've ever seen.

FYC: Keanu Reeves https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AvaCWTkSXdE

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I kept having urges to watch The Shining while I was watching this!

reply