MovieChat Forums > Dad's Army (1968) Discussion > Your Least Favourite Character

Your Least Favourite Character


What's your least favourite Character.

Mine is probably Private Cheesman no replacement for Walker but his WC armband was very funny, or it could be The Town Clerk, I don't why, he just annoys me.

reply

my least fav character is Walker he seems drab and boorish, he just hung on there too long...

reply

"He just hung on there too long"


You mean he took too long to die? A little inconsiderate don't you think?

There was rarely a bad episode where he was the central figure and he was damned near impossible to replace after his death. If anything his replacement Cheeseman was the most annoying, if only because he didn;t seem to meld with the rest of the cast.

reply

The series was the best with Walker, but I wouldn't say he's hilarious. Cheeseman and Sponge they could have dropped completely.

Of the most regular characters, the warden is probably my least favorite. Of course he was written to be unsympathetic, but I never found him very funny.

Thanks bridesmaid, like the beard. -Blackadder II

reply

Will you Yanks ever learn that to practice good comedy, you need a few clowns but also quite a few 'straight men.'

Air warden Hodges was the funniest character not because he was played that way. He was funny because to me, even at the age of 5, it was Hodges who was the Walmington Home Guard's most hated enemy! NOT the Germans or even Hitler!

I can still remember the episode (haven't seen it on re-airings and never watched it religiously anyway) where Hodges, together with the vicar's clerk, attempt to infiltrate and sabotage a rather complex training exercise of the Guard. The guardsmen must camouflage their position while an airforce plane tries to spot them.

Hodges and his cronies intend to hold up a big sign saying "They are there!" after which the plane will drop paint on the position.

Think you can trust your cat? Think Again!

reply

Straight men like the vicar?

That gag you mention was funny because it was a funny idea, not because of Hodges. Whenever he had to act funny, like getting himself stuck in the mud next to Jones' truck, he would always overreact too much to be funny.

And I'm not a Yank by the way.

Thanks bridesmaid, like the beard. -Blackadder II

reply

I didn't really like Mr Yateman the verger. I do accept, like Hodges, he is used as a straight man and so put up with him.

However I do not agree that Walker made teh series drab, quite the opposite actually. Havin watched this series on repeats from a young age and more recently on dvd my views of certain characters has changed dramatically. When I was younger I didn't like Walker becaus I found him unfunny, mainly due to his adult themed jokes but now that I'm older I love adn laugh at his wry comments adn cockney humour. An integral part of the show's lasting and brilliance

reply

The vicar was a real ham...and so was Hodges...even more so! But that made it all the more real, as you do get those people in life, and they are often in those types of roles. A bit of authority goes straight to their head.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

You are right. They all complemented each other beautifully.

reply

(aside to earlier poster - remarkable how you can turn a thread about characters in 'Dad's Army' into an attack on Americans; good show...)

My least favourite character, were I FORCED to choose one - and this might appear sacrilegous - is Jack Jones. I think Clive Dunn overplayed the part. Granted, part of the Jones character is to be overplayed - I just find Dunn's mugging a bit too much at times. That said, I'm engaging in nit-pickery as the whole cast did a wonderful job.

"Someone has been tampering with Hank's memories."

reply

Jones is my all time favorite.

I prefered Cheeseman in his first appearance.

Captain square is a bit annoying.

But the character who really gets my goat is Mainwaring. Mainly due to the fact that he is so snobbish and thinks he is right all the time.

reply

robert-veryardl-1: "But the character who really gets my goat is Mainwaring. Mainly due to the fact that he is so snobbish and thinks he is right all the time."
-----------------------------------------------------------------

And that was the flaw of the character, that he thought he was right all the time. As an American, I had not an ever-lovin' clue waht the vast bulk of these characters were about, but I grew to wholly appreciate them, especially Mainwaring.

My favorite episode with him is 'Mums Army' in which he gets himself a woman of his own (played by Carmen Silvera, who would go on to appear on Allo Allo).

I think it is this episode I'm watching now, I have few of them recorded, in which they are having a dance and at the end, Mainwaring is drunk, for no reason, but he is hilarious trying to sound like he knows what he is talking about while sauced.

reply

Hi - don't worry about the 'American' jibe - it's nice to have an American appreciate this series. But how did you get into it? Did u see it on the BBC (America) channel, or you been to Britain etc? Take care, mate!

reply

naseby: "Hi - don't worry about the 'American' jibe - it's nice to have an American appreciate this series. But how did you get into it? Did u see it on the BBC (America) channel, or you been to Britain etc? Take care, mate!"
----------------------------------------------------------------

How about a little American history lesson on British television? Ready?

In America, we have an educational network where we watch Sesame Street, the network is called ETV (Educational television). ETV began circa 1969 or 1970 (when it was available in my area).

When ETV (which has no commercials even today) had timeslots to fill and had to get cheap programming, they obtained a British comedy called Monty Python. I'm sure you are familiar with that.

I don't know when Monty Python aired back then (I'm sure it was late at night), but it was a huge hit with American college students.

So ETV knew to just get British comedies and programming and put that on.

This led of course to Fawlty Towers.

Now 30 years ago, I do recall seeing Fawlty Towers (and had not a clue what was wrong with that man).

Another show turned up, called To The Manor Born, no doubt because its final episode was the highest rated episode in the UK (until the finale of Only Fools and Horses).

Now I do recall some of Dad's Army even back then. I think the only episode I saw involved Mainwaring with a grenade down his pants. Or was it Jones?

This then brought us to early 1980s and a certain timelord.

Tom Baker had finished his run as the Doctor and now America was getting him and he became an incredible cult hit, airing five days a week in the afternoons.

There was yet another lapse of sorts (Doctor Who was running into its problems and I was getting older), and then we got another show called Are You Being Served? in the latter 1980s.

Like Doc Who, AYBS apparently came to America after the show had ended in the UK.

And like Doc Who, AYBS was run into the proverbial ground in reruns here.

In no time, we were handed Hyacinth Bucket (pronounced, . . . yes) and that was it.

After that, it was put on Britcoms (what we call the shows over here) and see if they get an audience, on the ETV network.

i don't have BBC America, tho, but on ETV alone, I've seen Vicar of Dibley, Allo Allo (not a fave), As Time Goes By (another unfave), One Foot in the Grave (pulled much too soon), Brittas Empire (also pulled much too soon).

Quite a while back, we had Don't Wait Up (actually very funny) and To The Manor Born again.

Mulberry has aired a couple of times, I recorded it to dvd last time it aired.

We were even given 'One Season Wonders' with The Savages, Office Gossip, Brotherly Love and that one about the little village that seceded from the UK. I recorded them all.

Dad's Army turned up a couple of years ago, when I managed to get the virtual smattering of shows I have (about one and a half).

Oh, yes, we had Mr. Bean and Thin Blue Line.

I had to buy Black Adder, AbFab, Only Fools and Horses, 12 eps of Hi De Hi and 12 eps of On The Buses.

AYBS was run into the ground so badly, for a while we were given Come Back Mrs Noah, with Mollie Sugden, but that wasn't six episodes, was it?

Oh yea, just before AYBS, we had Good Neighbors, which is the Good Life in England, isn't it? No idea why the title was changed.

I think that has been it (we had a show called 'Barbara' but I never watched that one).

Only one out of this loop I can recall was Red Dwarf, which aired on another network, late night on Saturdays.

Oh, I forgot to mention. My mother is English.

Oops, forgot. There was also a very brief airing of Oh Dr. Beeching (having seen Hi De Hi and On the Buses, I woulnd't mind seeing Dr. Beeching again), and My Hero had a pretty strong run for a while.

we currently have As Time Goes By, Hyacinth, Allo Allo and Fawlty Towers. With so few Fawlty eps, I expect it to vanish soon and wait to see what replaces it.

reply

Quite an eye-opener, that one, Richard! Thanks!

reply

naseby: "Quite an eye-opener, that one, Richard! Thanks!"
----------------------------------------------------------------

I just felt like rollin'. lol!

I'm sure alot more shows are available on BBC America. Someone at my work who has BBC America keeps asking me about programs and I tell him I have no idea what he is talking about. I've never seen them.

Currently, Fawlty Towers is running on Saturday night with Hyacinth, As Time Goes By and allo Allo.

Fawlty won't be rerun over and over (with only 12 or 14 eps?), but I think at the moment it is taboo to remove Hyacinth.

Everyone just enjoys watching this snooty woman make a fool of herself, as well as her embarrassing family (who cross all cultural barriers, I might add. Everyone has an Onslow, Daisy and Rose in their family.)

I'll be waiting to see what show is ushered in to replace Fawlty. If it is Dad's Army again, Iwill have to make a supreme effort to record them off this time.




reply

[deleted]

I'm really surprised by some that don't turn up, such as Father Ted or Days of Wine and Roses, to name but two. Alan Partridge hasnt turned up as well. I've heard the name tho.

During the AYBS craze, we got Mrs. Noah, which of course was only six episodes, so they must have gotten it cheap, but we never got the one John Inman did with wasn't it Rula Lenska? Where he was her secretary?

I'm just surprised we didn't get something else Inman, or it was too expensive a gamble for ratings.

But Vicar of Dibley was so charming and My Hero was rather well received, wasn't George Sunday (Ardal O'Hanlon) in Father Ted as well? I'm surprised the deduction wasn't that this one would get good ratings. I'm fairly certain Arthur Lowe was as excellent in Father Ted as he was in Dad's Army.

I'm really not sure what Wine and Roses is about, I gather it is elderly gentlemen, but if it is remotely English flavored and full of charm, as well as it eventually added Frank Thornton to the cast, then I don't know what is keeping it off the regular American networks.

Only Fools and Horses, I've seen, and yes, it is too British.

Oh yes, we got Chef as well at one time, actually has circulated a couple of times.

reply




No-one seems to have mentioned Pike - like everyone else, I love the show and I'm only picking him because I have to, but his childish ways I sometimes found irritating rather than funny. His voice used to get a bit strident sometimes which grated on my ears too, but on occasion he could be very funny - like when he told Mainwaring that he had dropped him in it with his wife on the phone (by telling her Mainwaring was having coffee with a woman). As Mainwaring delivers the inevitable "Stupid boy", with more venom than usual, Pikey sort of smiles and nods acceptingly, as though even he agrees that on this occasion he is, indeed, a stupid boy.




My body makes no moan
But sings on:
All things remain in God.

reply

''I'm fairly certain Arthur Lowe was as excellent in Father Ted as he was in Dad's Army.''

I believe that you mean 'Bless Me, Father', which I have never seen.

''I'm really not sure what Wine and Roses is about, I gather it is elderly gentlemen, but if it is remotely English flavored and full of charm, as well as it eventually added Frank Thornton to the cast, then I don't know what is keeping it off the regular American networks.''

I had no idea what this was until this paragraph. We call that 'Last of The Summer Wine' in the UK.



Formerly KingAngantyr

reply

Wow...Richard,many thanks for that.....And before I forget: Ignore the 'Yanks' jibe...totally uncalled for, I'm just glad that people...ANYWHERE on the planet enjoy the many TV programmes we love in Britain....(er,sorry...I don't live there anymore, I'm in South America.) But what you say certainly makes me proud of UK TV comedy in general....I think they do it rather well on the whole.
There have been a few (mmm, rather a lot actually) of flops though.
Strange to think that both Fools & Horses & Dads Army were almost dropped after the first couple of showings..... I think that just shows how difficult it is to gauge eventual audience reaction to even the best of humour.
Time only,eventually, proves it. Unfortunately, we live in a world of Fast Fix.

I was intrigued by your comment: "When ETV (which has no commercials even today)"
That speaks volumes I think: I have long argued against those who attack the BBC simply because it "theoretically" requires a licence to view, but is,thank God, free of commercials & propaganda.
(Standby for a snowstorm of protest.)
But programmes such as those we are discussing here bear the point out perfectly.
The BBC still has a fine core of people who know what is good, what is bad, & what even they sometimes stumble upon, quite by chance is either of those.
They have skill. They have verve. But best of all, they are driven by something that money just cannot fathom: an innate sense of what they do.. is good.
And. That it means something. Even to some old some old fart in South America.

I guess what I am saying is that despite many recent mis-givings about the BBC, it still remains a gigantic force in the world of television. Let's not forget.

Keep on enjoying the programmes Richard.Sincere thanks for the considered reply.
Best regards.

reply

But that was the idea about Mainwaring - he was a snob, and bitterly resented that although he was the bank manager and the officer, he knew Wilson was the 'real deal' public school and all that. I think the characters were beautifully drawn, and each one provided a piece of the whole - there was a lot of over the top mugging at times, but I really loved that show, and it remains part of a very happy young adulthood.

reply

"my least fav character is Walker he seems drab and boorish, he just hung on there too long..."

What a tasteless comment!!!
I liked Walker

reply

What few eps appeared in America and that I can recall, my least fave would have to be the vicar. He just didn't fit with any of the others, connecting with them or anything.

He seems to be terribly minor, from waht I can recall.

Of the major ones, the one I recall disliking the most, tho I have since paid attention and realized waht he is doing, is John Le Mesieur.

Mainwaring soon pointed out to me what Wilson was all about tho.

reply

Silly vicars are compulsory. There's no loophole, I'm afraid.

reply

Sorry to say it but out of the main cast members mine is Corporal Jones, I realise he was a vital part of the show but I just found the character annoying and repetative. I do not dislike the character but with the acting and writing being so strong I found his character the weakest of the 7 main platoon members. My favourires in order would be Mainwaring, Wilson, Frazer, Walker, Pike, Godfrey and Jones.

reply

[deleted]

dont know i could pick one , but sometimes the special guest's character's were annoying like captain cutts specialy in round went the great big wheel.

reply

Actually i stopped buying the DVD's after Walker/James Beck stopped being in the show as Mr Cheeseman was a poor replacement. I do like Hodges though, his 'Napoleon' references are amusing and some of the terrible things that happened to him (like when he got horribly drunk in the episode when they are stuck on the pier) are worth watching. Of all the regulars i'm afraid i found Jonesy the most irritating. I found him to be very predictable after the novelty wore off and i found him the least convincing and most grating of all the characters ( i think thats a fault of the writing and not Clive Dunn though), although he does get one episode where he shines, The Three and a half Feathers.

Personally my 3 fave characters have got to Godfrey, Mainwairing and Fraser. Brilliantly acted and written.

reply

Frazer had a really nasty streak.....

reply

The welsh one who took over from Walker/James Beck. He was awful, which is why he wasn't in it too long. I also am not keen on Hodges.

reply

Well to start with - I loved Jones .. some people think he was overplayed but he cracks me up almost every scene he's in.. same with Frazer.

My least favourite was... maybe the verger.... but thats really nitpicking because they all gave a wonderful performance.

reply

I think it's quite easy for people to say that Cheesman was some people's least favourite purely because he took over from James Beck. Of the main cast i'd probably say my least favourite character is Fraser, but out of the whole show my least favourite character is probably The Town Clerk, Claude Gordon, although he's a very nice man in real life.

reply

I agree with you re Cheeseman. I think he suffered more because people saw him as a very poor substitute for the loveable rogue Walker. Couple that with the tragic and sudden way James Beck died and I think that is why Cheeseman was not popular. Having said all that, I don't think his character fitted with the general atmosphere of the show and would probably have been unpopular anyway. I also would say that Fraser was my least favourite, mostly because he was not to be trusted and gave the impression that he would sell anyone out to save himself. However, in the final episode he redeems himself somewhat when Hodges suggests the Nazis would walk stright through the Home Guard. Jones says he would stand firm against them and Fraser adds that he would be right there next to Jones and the others. Maybe not so bad after all?!! Superb show, though, and untouchable for humour and class.

reply

Fraser changed a lot -- by about 1975-6 he was doing things 'out of character' like single-handedly saving Godfrey and his sisters' home by blackmailing his old school mate the minister of works into shifting the planned aerodrome, then allowing Mainwaring to take credit as the hero.

reply

I agree; I found corporal Jones really annoying and he was not in the least bit funny. In fact he ruined the series for me as his 'humour' is based, and relies totally on, stupidity, which is just not funny. The scenes between Captain Mainwaring and Sgt Wilson I found to be the funnniest; Wilson's barely concealed contempt for Mainwaring and Mainwaring's jealousy of Wilson's superior social class provided many hilarious interchanges, which were often quite subtle. My favourite line is probably Mainwaring's "Don't tell him Pike!".

reply

[deleted]

I don't think wilson despised Mainwaring. I remember one episode where he tells mainwaring he has done wonders with the platoon, and i think he is sincere. He does think he is unwise sometimes, but that's not despising him.

reply

Got a point with Cheeseman, though some of you have made a point with Jonesey - although a great character, he did come out with it a bit. I mean, even if all the characters had a repetative nature, you still can't help laughing at Godfrey saying he must have 'dozed off', Frazer stating 'we're all doomed' Pikey
'telling mum', Walker just about having anything going as 'dodgy', Wilson's deadpan delivery 'do you think that's wise, sir?' etc etc. When Jones opened his gob, after a few series, you were saying to yourself 'Oh, no, here he goes again' but cheeseman has my vote (as the least likeable).

reply

Cheesman and then Jones. Cheeseman just because he didn't fit in with the rest of them. They should have left the gap there, once Beck's died, not try and fill the gap caused by his passing. No one could replace him the show felt that little bit more empty after he was gone. And Jones, although he isn't a waste of space like Cheeseman, he is really repetative after a while giving us the same old same old each time, over doing it as usual. Not very funny at all after the fiftieth time.

"Face to face and steel to steel, how does the Scotsman's anger feel?!"

reply

While Jones over the top moments can get old after a while when they gave him something a more low key he pulls them off wonderfully.

I love the episode where Mainwearing is drawing on Jone's van in order to illustrate his plan, and Jones pipes up: "Captain Mainwearing, you're not allowed to wreck my van, thats for Hitler to do"

reply

[deleted]

My least favourite was Godfrey. He had no character. He was simply old and doddery and I didn't find that entertaining.

reply

My least favourite character was Private Cheeseman, Talfryn Thomas had a massive pair of shoes to step into after Jimmy Beck died, what Jimmy Perry and David Croft should have done was not replace Beck, but used the other extra e.g Colin Bean(Pvt Sponge) more, and use people who had already been there for the duration of the show

If There Is More Life In Sperm Than Blood, Why Doesn't Dracula Suck D*ck Instead

reply

My least favourite is Mr. Yeatman, I think.


Darling, We're the Young Ones
Hammersmith Hardwoman #11

reply

My least favourite is any of the extra Home Guardsmen. They seem to be in the frame whenever Frazer or Jones makes a speech and the actors just look bored to death, it's really off putting and disrespectful.

I'm British, don't hold it against me.

reply

Mr Yeatman the verger. I wasn't needed really... Hodges and his band of warderns were enough

reply

It may seem a bit biased but I like all the characters, I just don't know what there is to dislike about them.

_____________

Jesus, that's super... How'da nitwit like you get so tasteful?

reply

Of the main characters, Pike is my least favorite. Not that he's bad, mind you, he's just not particularly funny.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

exactly what i thought,a real brown nose,he really deserved a punch in the face

reply

[deleted]