MovieChat Forums > F Troop (1965) Discussion > Can 'F Troop' be remade into a motion pi...

Can 'F Troop' be remade into a motion picture?


If so can anyone help me with ideas for casting? I haven't thought of any myself but can anyone who reads this help me out? Thanks.

reply

Are you speaking to me?

Bobby

reply

OK I apologize for saying you should go to jail for making F-troop into a movie. I certainly didn't mean it literally, as my statement was made in jest.

But seriously don't you have anything better to do? Originality is dead in Hollywood. I mean, why bother trying to come up with anything original when it's so much easier to just re-make the work of someone else?

Good luck on your project. Just don't expect me to buy a ticket.

Teresa
http://MermaidLady.com

reply

Teresa,

Apology accepted. Although I feel compelled to answer your "...don't you have anything better to do?" question:

Yes, I have many "better" things better to do. And I do them often. I help with the Union Rescue Mission in downtown L.A. once a week assisting our homeless folks; I teach (unpaid) a class in filmmaking for a bunch of 6th graders; and I donate my time and financial assistance to several other charities.

So, yes -- I do have better things to do. But making movies, comedy movies, is both my business and career.

Is it okay with you if I pursue making a living?

Further -- allow me to answer your "...why bother trying to come up with anything original when it's so much easier to just re-make the work of someone else?" question/accusation:

Have you seen any of my work? Any of my previous four feature films? Any of my five network pilots? Any of my many FOX or ABC network specials? Or have you ever heard any of the over 50 comedians and comediennes that I've written for over the years (including people as diverse as Joan Rivers, Rodney Dangerfield, Sam Kinison, Garry Shandling)?

I assure you that ALL of the material that I write is ORIGINAL. It's hard to sell anything that isn't original, Teresa.

Now, regarding "F Troop" -- I kind of understand where you are coming from. You are tired of seeing "TV series turned into feature films." To you this is probably "not original" and therefore you think "...it's so much easier to just re-make the work."

Oh, really? You think so?

Do you think it was easy to turn "Gone With The Wind" from a book into a movie?

Or "Mission Impossible" from a TV series into a movie?

Or "The Producers" from a movie into a Broadway Musical?

Or "MASH" from a book -- then into a movie -- then into a TV series?

Trust me -- it ain't easy. Matter of fact it is VERY hard. And the main reason is because the writer has to make the original source material EVEN BETTER if he or she has even the most remote shot at making it a success.

So, Teresa, trust my 25 years of experience when I tell you that it is not "easier to re-make the work." It's much harder.

I can go on and on with examples, but hopefully you're catching my drift here.

BTW, Teresa, it's called "show business." Notice the word "business" in there? These are entertainment projects that we create to (obviously) entertain people. But, they are mainly made to make... a buck. These projects employ millions of people. From the cast and crew, to the studio executives, to the theater workers, etc. They are important to the economy. Something to keep in mind.

I am a comedy filmmaker, Teresa. It is what I do. And to have the opportunity to try and turn my favorite TV show ("F Troop") into a movie is both a privilege AND a smart business idea.

If I had a dime for everyone who told me how they'd LOVE to see "F Troop" on the big screen I'd have the film financed by now.

So, there ya go. I've posted my reply to your (qualified) apology.

Hopefully you will not feel I'm replying to you in a condescending manner.

...Oh, by the way, "condescending" means to "talk down to someone." ;)

Bobby

reply


Hey, it's a free country.

Teresa
http://MermaidLady.com

reply

Bobby has said that it's unclear if you, Tutt, are in fact speaking to him. If you are then take the following message to heart. If you weren't then ignore it, but it did look like you were speaking to him.

To tutt that said that the very potential filmmaker of "F Troop" should be put in jail for life if he did make a movie of "F Troop". Well, here's an idea. Take a *beep* load of prozac and get a life! It's a movie adaptation of a 1960's comedy for crying out loud.

reply

F-Troop was also my favorite TV show when I was a kid. I remember being in 4th grade at the time and wanting to not only be in the show but live in it as if it was real. Probably the reason why I asked to be placed in the 11th armored calvary when I arrived in Germany in the early 80's.

If wriiten and cast correctly this movie will work. If it does go PC it will flop and not stay true to it's core. I'd think you'd probably have to go more independant than mainstream studio. The idea of casting Indians to play the Hekawis is pretty smart but may not be neccessary for every one to be.

Good luck with the script. I hope this happens.

Scott

reply

I assure you that you would like the screenplay, and I plan on assembling the very best cast possible.

I will ONLY have Native Americans play ALL of the roles of the Hekawis. I'm doing this for several reasons, mostly because it's simply the right thing to do. I wouldn't hire caucasian actors to portray African-Americans, ya know?

I appreciate your good wishes, Scott. Here's hoping I can make a nice announcement shortly...

Bobby

reply

F Troop -- The Movie... = Bewitched -- The Movie...

Bad, Sad Idea IMAO

Point. Anybody buy the defective 4 Season of The Andy Griffth Show? There were 4 episodes that did NOT contain the canned laugh track. The episodes just didn't work and Paramount made good by providing replacements. My point is that all the old filmed half hour sit-coms had that dumb laugh track, but it did make the show run smooth. IMO that's the major problems with 1/2 hour sit-coms made in to movies. Just a bad idea!

"There are 10 kinds of people, half understand binary and half don't!"

reply

Let me get this straight -- because 1/2 hour shows had a laugh track it's not a good idea to turn them into movies??

That's like saying M*A*S*H was only funny outside of the E.R. because they didn't have a laugh track.

Huh?

Bobby

reply

Remember M*A*S*H was a movie BEFORE it was a TV show. And it was just a bit more semi-serious the first few seasons then just became even more of an Alan Alda polictical statement than the movie. Generally most history proves that 1/2 hour TV show just make terrible 'Theactrical Features". Just opining here.

"There are 10 kinds of people, half understand binary and half don't!"

reply

Oh, I understand your opining. But, let me counter by offering several examples of 1/2 TV shows that did VERY well as theatrical films:

The Addams Family ------ $197,000,000 gross

The Flintstones ------ $358,000,000 gross

Bewitched ------ $131,000,000 gross

The Brady Bunch ------ $198,000,000 gross

The Beverly Hillbilles ------ $123,000,000 gross

I can continue if you'd like, but I think you get the point. Hollywood is all about one thing: making money. Period. And they will continue to turn 1/2 TV series (as well as hour long) into feature films because they make money.

Built-in familiarity -- aka "branding."

FWIW.

Bobby

reply

Bobby, an excellent point. Sadly, IMO, more than most fail to capture the spirit of the original script. "The Lone Ranger" was pathetic, "The Wild, Wild West" ohh, and even Don Adams lamented how poorly "The Nude Bomb" was.

BUT, setting aside 'Hillbillies' and especially 'Bewitched', some are very good and some even shine! The two "The Brady Bunch" movies were a brilliant lampoon at the ever so iconic conservative to psychedelic '70's sitcom.

If they could come up with a great cast, (some of the suggestions have been great), and create a screenplay that is funny (without gross-out humor) and appealing to everybody (a movie I can take my young grandkids to), AND INCLUDING the original viewing demographic; then I will be the first in line for tickets. As great as they are in their own right, I don't want the movie to 'belong' to a Jim Carey or an Adam Sandler. ALL the characters need to be able to display their comedic talents.

Thinking of F - Troop, LOL, Duffy is the one that just cracks me up. "There I was, me and Davy Crockett at the Alamo....". Hell they were all great!

MTCW

Mike


"There are 10 kinds of people, half understand binary and half don't!"

reply

Mike,

I agree with all of your points (good screenplay ... which, BTW, I think I have written), excellent cast, and staying true to the family audience.

These are the points I promise to bring to an "F Troop" movie.

And, yes, I loved Duffy. Bob Steele was perfectly cast in that role.

Bobby

reply

Very well then! I like that kind of thinking.

(LOL)You just gotta love cowboy Bob Steele as Duffy. He cracks me up just thinking of some of his script.

Okay, Bobby, the best of luck with your F-Troop endeavor.

M

"There are 10 kinds of people, half understand binary and half don't!"

reply

Wild Eagle has to be played by Jonathan Winters - besides he's part Indian

reply

Unfortunately, Jonathan is very old -- and not well. The role requires much more physical agility than he can possibly handle.

Otherwise, great idea.

Bobby

reply

I thought Jonny was in pretty good shape? I'll have to check that out.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

You know it's only a matter of time since Hollywood is bereft of any original ideas. In fact it's almost guaranteed. And it's not to impugn the original show which I loved.

On the other hand, because of political correctness--which is in full force on these boards--it is doubtful they will make "F Troop" into a film

reply

Hollywood NEVER had original ideas.

reply

I would love to see all of the troopers played by Native Americans with absolutely horrific European names. Trooper van Liederhosen, Hennesey Shaunessy, Jauque LaTrine etc etc. This would be partial pay back for all of those actors playing Indians as a joke.

reply