MovieChat Forums > Fail Safe (1964) Discussion > Very moving conversation between Gen. Bo...

Very moving conversation between Gen. Bogan and his Soviet counterpart


Their ending said it all.

"Goodbye my friend."
"Goodbye my friend."

reply

Yeah, this is to counter Groteschele's paranoia that they are not like us. Nice touch.




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

To me, this was the most powerful part of the movie. At first, the Soviets are a faceless adversary. Even when Bogan was cooperating with Marshal Nevski, it was still just a faceless voice with all the lingering mistrust that led others to defy or be reluctant to follow orders to aid the Soviets. Even Nevski retained his own doubts of our sincerity, which resulted in his orders to go after a decoy plane. But then, after Nevski's failure and collapse, a file was given to Bogan on Nevski's successor, which contained a photo of the person. No longer a faceless voice, the barriers begin to come down. The two are able to share common experiences, with Bogan even asking if his counterpart was about to die in Moscow. -Bogan even started to ask if his family was still in Moscow, but couldn't even finish the question. "It's been a hard day."

Roast beef and swiss,
On marble rye bread,
With lettuce, onion,
And horseradish spread.

reply

Less than twenty years before-truly a short time, the American and Soviet officers were allies against an even Bigger Enemy, which was Hitler's Nazism-despite the Cold War animosities, it must have been hard amongst many involved who had lived those days, to have to face off against one another, as enemies-especially those younger Russian officers, that knew that-without the West's help, they'd have suffered even more from Germany's War machine...so to them, indeed, Americans were Friends-and viceversa-those who'd been near the Russians, knew how much they suffered...it's indeed a poignant moment...Russians are incurable Romantics, and this scene shows just how much that poor Russian officer knew he was painted against a corner, and there was nothing that could be done about it, but also knew it was not their former ally's complete fault either...

reply

it must have been hard amongst many involved who had lived those days, to have to face off against one another, as enemies-especially those younger Russian officers, that knew that-without the West's help, they'd have suffered even more from Germany's War machine...


I think this undermine the extreme efford the Soviets made during WWII.

They lost 20 million lives from the time Hitler initiated operation Barbarossa in 1941, until the Soviet flag (note that!) waved over the Reichskanslerbuiling in Berlin in May 1945.

The Russian and Soviet nations fought the Germans on the eastern-front for 4 years.
The invasion of Normandy was June 1944, at that point, the Germans were already on the run and had ben shun from Russian soil.

Had the invasion of Normandy never happened, the Russians would probably have marched on to the Atlantic, decimating Hitlers forces.

Stalin didn't mind feeding his people to the meat-grinder to defeat Hitler and he would have crushed his opponent without allied help.

It is not the Russians that owe the US and allies or need to be thankful, it's the other way around actually; Thanks to the Russians, Hitler was smashed and the western-front weakened, so the allies could get a foothold.

It was he Russians that liberated my own country.

I don't like Stalin or commies, but I am very diligent of who to be thankful for when it comes to WWII, namely the Soviets, who's effort has been downplayed for 70 years, so it looks like it was USA and her allies that came in and saved Europe.

reply

I love how we are all trying to get in last-minute chats before the boards close, lol.

Just a note about the Russian death toll during WWII. In school, we were told it was 50 million, and I was like, "wow, those guys gave their all." Decades later, a Ukrainian-American explained to me that those figures are not entirely due to the war. Around that time period, my friend said Stalin was simultaneously conducting "The Purges," scouring the countryside, killing 20-30 *million* soviet citizens.

I was flabbergasted. And why was this wholesale murder of so many not common knowledge before now?

I was equally ignorant not knowing that the Russians initially sided with Hitler. I feel like as a USA student decades ago, there was a lot that they didn't tell us. :-(

reply

They were indeed Friends, in the only way Soldiers of different Nations face a Common enemy-even if they later became foes, they showed respect and solidarity for each other...the fact that, when looking at his dossier, the American sees a Noble-looking man, with the worldly sadness of a man who'd seen Death and Destruction, and another image that showed this man as a Loving husband and father, was evidently a way to debunk the image that Walter's character wants to put forward of Soviets as inhuman creatures...

reply

That to me though is the thing about this film that is so fundamentally dishonest. The Soviet Union *was* filled with inhuman creatures throughout most if its existence with a legacy of human rights atrocities to rival or even in some cases surpass those of Hitler (their ally from 1939-41). And all of it didn't just stem from the mindset of Lenin or Stalin anymore than Nazi genocide could solely come from Hitler's inhumanity. We totally shame the victims of that genocide by embracing the notion that this film tried to peddle that the Cold War was a big nothing and that those who talked of the inhumanity of the Soviet regime were somehow the more evil people.

reply

incoherent

reply

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.....................

reply

Very effectively acted. I just saw it again tonight and it really stood out.

reply