social issues


Great movie...had me laughing and thinking both. There is a post in one of the other threads that seems to imply that if a movie is a comedy it cannot be serious or push serious social issues, which I strongly disagree with. I am a fan of JW, although not a worshipper. I found it interesting that the movie seems to push so fervently for the rights of Native Americans. Yet, it seems to be disprespectful toward them at the same time. Especially the one in the red broadcloth. He is a comic element, but the comic elements highlighted are poking fun using stereotypes of American Indians: his speech and how he repeatedly says things like "Big party, no whiskey!" and acts like a fool.
This is probably obvious, but the other issue I had was that of the feminists. What would the feminist criticism for this film be? Especially the idea that women need to be tamed through beating them with hard metal objects. Mrs. Mclintock seems also to forgive her husband without having her primary issue resolved. I, as a viewer, was still left with the impression that he had been unfaithful to her, with the barmaids or whoever, although obviously not with Mrs Warren. Yet suddenly she forgives him, although he never declares himself innocent of this, and the movie ends with him yelling, "Happy Day" and turning her bedroom light off.
My last question is, what did the whole hat thing mean? Sorry, that one got past me. Did it symbolize somethign or mean something when he threw his hat up there?

reply

I knew that this would come up. It is not a perfect World, nor a perfect film. If it were made today, it would "sellout" and be like you want it to be. It would be a complete bore. This movie represents a viewpoint, and viewpoints are viewpoints. I don't see the Native Americans treated with disrespect. Instead, of being shown in some "pc" way where they sit and smoke the "peace pipe" all day, they are portrayed as people with a view and a cause. They respect McClintock as a former enemy to be admired for his bravery. They don't exactly agree at the end, but they go their separate ways.
As far as the women part, it is supposed to be a comedy. You think that husbands and wives don't fight and argue with each other. I think so. I think McClintock knows he has flaws, and no one knows exactly what they were. He may have just flirted with a few barmaids, and his wife thinks that he cheated. You don't know. That's the point. They resolved their arguments.
The hat was part of a brag, because McClintock threw it so high that it stuck on the weathervane. Everything is a sport, and a competition to McClintock. I think this is a funny comedy, and one shouldn't take it too literally. Have fun. Relax. Enjoy.

reply

The reason movies are so boring nowadays is because there is no comedy in them. They're politically correct snoozefests where only conservative, Christian, heterosexual white males can be poked fun at. Every other group must be worshipped and treated as if they're much more intelligent even though there are intelligent people and dummies in every group. I'll take the old movies like this one over the pc garbage coming out of Hollywood nowadays. And where did this crap about calling Indians "native Americans" come from? My grandfather was a Choctaw and he called himself a Choctaw Indian.

reply

Ridgerunner, you are right!

"McLintock" is a funny movie, but it could probably not be made today. Too many P.C. types telling you what you can and can't do, and who you offend or don't offend.

It is one of my favorites and I am happy to say that when it came out on DVD I was able to get the correct version, not the bootleg that was making the rounds.

Gabe

reply

Make it anyway and let them.howl!
Didn't care for Wayne all.but disinheriting his daughter- what if she didn't want to be a rancher's wife?

reply

[deleted]

I believe that the instincts and hormones a woman is equipped with make her want a strong, "take charge" kind of man.


reply