Just watched that scene frame by frame and all I see are two M1 Garands.
That actually makes it a bigger goof.
And of course you can tell, by the flat pouches, that their cartridge belts are empty. Also, they must have been National Guard troops since by 1962 the regular Army had long been re-equiped with the M14. (Which, of course, would have made the "machine gun" fire logical.)
Did you notice when Milland asks for handguns in the hardware store, Mr Johnson picks up a tray with three revolvers and one automatic. On that tray is only ONE box of ammunition which just so happens to be for the .45 auto.
Mr Johnson then says, "This 45's magnesium, light as a feather," and then hands what is obviously a full sized model to Ray Milland. The Colt Government (as well as the Star and Llama pistols often used as "stand-ins" in Hollywood) was 100% Steel (except for the stocks). The only lightweight .45 auto in the world at that time was the Colt Commander and it had what was then termed a "Duraluminum" frame and a shorter barrel.
Then when Milland asks, "How do you load it?" Johnson loads the magazine and says, "Just slip it back in." Racking the slide to load the chamber was never mentioned, but when Milland picks it up, he inserts the magazine and racks the slide.
Later on Milland remarks that Marilyn is "pretty good with a rifle." How does he know this since there was no scene with her firing a gun nor any previous dialogue mentioning it?
reply
share