Y'know, I've been reading posts about the 1934 movie IMITATION OF LIFE, with many comments on its racism, and not a few posters said that's "how it was".
Doesn't mean it was right, though.
Huh?
Racism was never "right." But what does that have to do with Rob and Laura living in New Rochelle with a son named Richie? You're not actually equating racism with a writer's decision to have Rob live in the suburbs, are you?
What do you suppose would have happened to this show if Rob and Laura weren't suburban parents?
I think it would still be successful.
And what do you suppose would have happened if "The Allen Brady Show" had four writers instead of three? And what if they were all men? And what if it was all set in Los Angeles and not New York City? We can speculate until the end of time, but the answer to each question would be the same: We have no way of knowing. The relevant point is, audiences and critics responded favorably to this show AS IT WAS - with Rob working in Manhattan & going home to New Rochelle.
But if you can actually produce a set of reviews from the 60s that said the concept of having Rob live in the suburbs was "stale," I'd love to read them. Because I never came across anything like that when the show was first broadcast.
reply
share