Fridge Horror


An expression used on the TV Tropes site.

"Fridge" means something you don't think about while watching but do think of later, like when you go to the fridge for a snack.

As I remember the plot, the protagonist, a young Sioux (probably about 18, give or take a year or so) named White Bull, finds that his beloved horse now belongs to Captain Miles Keogh of the Seventh US Cavalry and is unable to get it back.

The great Sioux War breaks out. At the Little Big Horn on June 25, 1876, Custer's battalion is wiped out. Keogh is killed. The horse, Tonka or Comanche, is wounded. White Bull is wounded.

In real history, unmentioned in the movie, the Sioux besiege the troops of Benteen and Reno for the rest of the day. On the next day, the 26th of June, the Sioux besiege the troops of Benteen and Reno. White Bull continues to lie on the battlefield. Detecting General Terry's force, the Sioux abandon the fight and move their great camp south down the Little Big Horn.

On the 27th of June, 1876, General Terry's forces arrive and make contact with Reno and Benteen and find the bodies of Custer's men. They find at least one wounded cavalry horse, Comanche and take him with them when they take Reno's wounded men for medical treatment.

And in the movie they also find White Bull and take him back for medical treatment and he ends up as the attendant in charge of Comanche - the horse that is now the mascot of the 7th Cavalry.

I don't remember if there were any other dead and wounded Sioux and Cheyenne left on Custer Ridge in the movie.

It would be a big anthropological problem if many Sioux bodies were shown on the battlefield, implying that the Sioux left all their dead (and sometimes only wounded) warriors there.

But if White Bull was the only dead or wounded Sioux left lying on the battlefield, there would be another problem. Why was he singled out to not be buried or have his wounds treated?

Imagine a pair of Sioux sightseers:

"Look there's that nice boy White Bull lying there dead!"

"At least he hasn't been scalped yet and thus his spirit has not been destroyed and he can have an afterlife. And he hasn't been mutilated yet so he will be perfectly fit in the afterlife."

"Not yet, but the soldiers might do that when they come, just as those women are doing to that dead soldier there. The nice thing to do would be to take his corpse away and bury it with proper rites and protect it from the soldiers."

"Yes, that would be the good thing to do. Let's go back to our teepee now and leave White Bull's corpse here for the soldiers to do whatever they want to with it."

And if they saw that White Bull was still alive, and he might survive if given proper medical treatment, and the soldiers might kill him or torture him if they found him alive, there could be a similar discussion resulting in a decision not to bother helping White Bull.

And supposedly every Sioux who went sightseeing on Custer Hill and saw White Bull lying dead or wounded also decided to leave him where he was, despite all the other dead and wounded Sioux being taken away.

So what terrible thing by Sioux standards (that we may hope was not very evil by our standards) could White Bull have done off screen that made the other Sioux all despise him so much they would leave him lying dead or wounded, hoping that the soldiers and their Sioux-hating Crow and Arikara scouts would do whatever they wanted to his living or dead body?

reply

I remember seeing some battlefields strew with both dead soldiers and dead indians in many western movies.

And of course in real life if the soldiers won only dead Indians would be left on the battlefield and if the Indians won only dead soldiers would be left on the battlefield.

So I just looked at a video of the ending of the movie and in the scene where Comanche/Tonka and White Bull are found on the battlefield by the soldiers there are some other dead Sioux & Cheyenne lying on the ground amoung the dead soldiers.

So that means that in the movie White Bull wasn't treated any differently than the other "dead" Sioux and Cheneye warriors.

When I first saw Tonka as a kid long ago, I sort of wondered why White Bull ended up in a soldier's uniform at the Fort at the end of the film. Maybe he didn't have any family or friends to go back to, and his only friend was the horse.

But if he was the only wonded warrior left on the battlefield to be found and probably killed and mutilated by the indian scouts of the army, he could feel like he was abandoned by his people, that they had turned against him, and that he had to find a new group to belong to.

But with all the other "dead" warriors lying around the battlefield, White Bull wouldn't feel like his people were against him.
Unless maybe he believed that the way all the "dead" warriors had been abandoned by their people was disgracefully ungrateful for their scrifices in battle and he didn't want to live among such ingrates anymore..

reply