MovieChat Forums > Auntie Mame (1958) Discussion > Why do so many gay people love this film...

Why do so many gay people love this film?


Curious to know why you think so many gay men love this film.

Let's hear your comments.

reply

I have to refer to Zilpha Keatley Snyder's 1970 book THE CHANGELING [changeling, a child of supernatural parents who had been exchanged for a human baby]. In the book the gals chat about adults who never really grow-up and what a true gem they really are, how few there are and that there are mostly women [gay men would not be mentioned in a child's book in those days]
Gay men constantly feel like changelings while growing up [I don't belong in this family, my family will disown me when the find out, etc...] and seeking out their 'real' progenitors is that adult who never really grew up....

Gosh, darn, I don't know. I just know that when I grew up, I had an aunt who never really grew up and she had children my age, and she lived in a beach community and I got to spend my summers there and she drove a '66 Rambler wagon. She is MY Auntie Mame!!!

reply

"...She is MY Auntie Mame!!!"

That's the whole appeal of AUNTIE MAME in a nutshell, and has been ever since the book first appeared - every has - or claims to have, or wants to have - an "Auntie Mame" in their lives. And who can blame them?

"I don't use a pen: I write with a goose quill dipped in venom!"---W. Lydecker

reply

Gay men love this film because the *stereotypical* gay man has the same tastes as a woman. They simply like what women like. Fabulous parties, gorgeous clothes, a big house to re-decorate whenever you please, etc. What *stereotypical* woman doesn't want that? Therefore, what *stereotypical* gay man wouldn't want that?

reply

I am gay, but I do not feel that that is a prerequisite for liking the film. I admire her totally Bohemian life style and have often wished I had an aunt like that. Sigh, no one in my family comes close to my eccentricness.

reply

We fail to see how or what sexual orientation has to do with appreciating AUNTIE MAME or any other film. If it is well made and the subject of interest most THINKING people will recognize its qualities. That is the important quotient to be a THINKING person. We have reviewed some of the other comments or message boards. Some of the reasons for not liking particular films we can only view as ludicrous. Examples;

1) Its in B&W, this is one (1) of the poorest. Anyone who makes that statement in a comment or message board should be deleted and banned from further contributions.

2) Its "old", which has various meanings from being made just ten (10) years ago to basically everything since World War II (WWII) to 1980. No doubt all films previous to this time period and all silents should be trashed based upon their limited interpetations of the artform.

3) There is no action in it, which is a euphanism for a lack of violence. As if killings and the more brutal the better is the sole mark of a great film.

4) It does not conform to our political or social beliefs. This is usually articulated by all those with their pet causes.

The list can go on. All you have to do is look through the comment sections or message boards. That is the trouble with these forums they become the dumping ground for the ignorant and the uniformed.

reply

Thank you, and BLESS you, xerses13!!!!
You have said it all! I`m all for going forward, and enjoying what life has to offer now and in the future, but I find the close minded attitudes on these boards, nothing but sad.
How can people limit themselves? They are missing out on so much!
I also find this a bit frightening too. Do these people extend their limited tastes to books, music and art? If so, there are a whole lot of uneducated individuals out there. I love the films and the music from my parent`s era...1920`s to..... I love MY era...1950`s to......
My child`s is intersting too! 1980`s to.....
I was taught that we learn from the past. It frightens me to think that so many people are`nt looking.

reply

I can't imagine why someone would post negative comments about Auntie Mame (& other classics) on this board! I have just wasted more time than I should have searching for these offensive posts you refer to. But I was reminded of a post I left a few months back. It seems that I've ruffled a few feathers by giving some thoughts and opinions about classic films: the thoughts and opinions expressed to me about classic films by MY HUSBAND. I get the feeling that my post was not read thoroughly and I would like to clear my name!
I am not into stereotypes or judging people/places/things. My taste in music, films, TV, clothes, household decor (you name it) are all about 50-60 years out of date. The clothes I wear are not in style and I don't give a crap about Brad Pitt's latest blockbuster. But I am married to a man who is only interested in what's fresh and new, what's current. If it was up to him, my mid-century Americana collections would go straight into the bucket. But what of it? He accepts me for rejecting modern day piffle. And I know I am not perfect. So I accept his disturbing assessment of Mildred Pierce before it's even out of the DVD case. It's true what they say about opposites. At least in my case. I'm sorry that my post seems to have been misinterpreted. Either way, thanks for your comments about my husband's lack of interest in classic films.



*I'd rather watch these old beauties with my gay co-worker anyway.*
P.S. thurber67, I meant to reply to the post left by xerses13.

reply

We are assuming you are referring to post dated 06/11/2006 15:46:26. No we had no trouble understanding it or that you were illustrating the differences in taste between your Husband and Yourself. Seems pretty clear. It is also clear that these differences do not really matter in the success of your relationship. Neither of your names need clearing nor do we detect anything that should offend anyone.

reply

DECORATORS???

reply

So the Gays that are not decorators means they have bad taste?

reply

[deleted]

"Books are soooooooooo decorative...."

"I don't use a pen: I write with a goose quill dipped in venom!"---W. Lydecker

reply

[deleted]

A better question would be, why DON'T heterosexual men give these films the appreciation they deserve?!?!

"They're all gonna laugh at you! They're all gonna laugh at you!

reply