MovieChat Forums > Crime of Passion (1957) Discussion > Decent noir, badly flawed as a social is...

Decent noir, badly flawed as a social issue film.


Kathy is literally cleaning out her desk and on the way to a great new job. Bill calls. She immediately drops everything and becomes a housewife. I know its the crux of the film but her rather extreme change of heart wasn't developed very well.

Then she's unhappy with her life, go figure, and yet never considers a job of any sort. It might be assumed that Bill doesn't want her to work after they're married, but there's never a scene with him forbidding her to work and he says over and over that he wants her to be happy. Also, as far as I can remember there was never any mention of children now or in the future.

There was some fairly good noir drama, Stanwyck was great, the agonizing dinner party scene was handled brilliantly, but the wife's-wasted-potential angle really fell flat. It seemed like Kathy was meant to be a sympathetic villain who was gloriously manipulative due to being repressed, instead her manipulations just felt sloppy and unfounded.

It's a shame too, considering that Crime of Passion was a little short at 84 minutes. it seems like a couple of extra scenes, 10-12 minutes worth, could have made this much stronger.

Hey fellas, this is yer Uncle Jim speakin'...

reply

well put... agreed.

reply

I agree with you,pillfeast.

reply

Nice post, pillfeast. I just finished watching this, I actually rewound it a bit because one minute Kathy and Bill are in San Francisco and the next they're declaring their undying love for each other, I had to make sure I didn't miss something. 

Sure, in movies the time it takes a lot of people to fall in love is compressed or handled with a title card (i.e. "Four years later"). With this, it's like it was three movies spliced together, one about women's workplace issues and one about suburban wives being bored and restless and another one about a crime.

Good job by Stanwyck, Hayden, Burr and the supporting cast, but a 6/10 for me.

reply

[deleted]

@pillfeast

You are so right. Should have let them add those much needed scenes to flesh out her character more. 🚨

Same Rules Apply

reply

Yeah, she's an intelligent, psychologically normal career woman, then within months she's gone completely mental, is manipulating everyone's lives, and hysterically blows a guy away. I don't buy it.

reply