MovieChat Forums > The Ladykillers (1956) Discussion > Comparison to Coen Brothers version

Comparison to Coen Brothers version



The old Ealing black comedy about robbers who are unable to murder an old lady who is their only link with the crime became a genuine classic in years. Although it seems a bit naive today, it didn't lose the charm. It is well-paced peace that use the minimalist type of humor; you probably won't laugh aloud, but you'll have a constant smile in the corner of your lips. The cast is brilliant, the screenplay is very good – but some scenes just seems so unrealistic today, like the one that old lady bugs the grocery salesman and the one where she insists on returning the money and they try to talk her out of it; the professor in the modern version at least offered her a part of the loot to keep her mouth shut.

Coen brothers moved the scene to the south of USA and they did a fair job, although it is one of their worst movies. Another plus in Coen's favor is Tom Hanks who made a great performance playing sweet-talking southern professor despite the fact he copied Guinness in some character elements than gave a totally new portrait, but the original just have more style and much more quality in general.

Movie remakes compared to original
http://www.movie-remakes.com

reply

This response may be a blast from the past, but I wanted to add my opinion to your thread. I much prefer the original to the Coen Brothers remake. It's one of my favourite black comedies of all time, but I did go and see the remake with an open mind because I thought, if anybody could do the original justice, it would be the Coen Brothers. I usually love their mixture of dark humour and skewed vision, but here I think they failed badly. The humour was crass and the acting overdone and the film just left me feeling sad and disappointed.

reply

No contest.

The original rocks!!

Its that man again!!

reply

I've heard a lot of complaining about the Coen Bros version. I'm probably one of the few people who actually likes it. I saw it about seven times in the theater, and I watch it every so often on DVD.

As for the original...let's just say that I'd rather watch Guinness in "Kind Hearts and Coronets" and "The Captain's Paradise". I've tried to watch this version of Ladykillers a couple of times now. I just can't get through it.

~~
Jim Hutton: talented gorgeous hot hunk; adorable as ElleryQueen; SEXIEST ACTOR EVER

reply