MovieChat Forums > Beat the Devil (1953) Discussion > is this really a comedy??

is this really a comedy??


I loved the movie.

But, when I bought it at the 99 cents store, it was in a boxed set with That Uncertain Feeling and advertised as Comedy Noir.

Was there a different view of comedy in the 40's and 50's? It is different than our current comedies.


ghostydoll
Proud Rumrunner!
Ghosty Rider

Puppy club Member!

reply

"How I got the car is not important!" One of the funniest lines in any movie.

reply

I liked the purser.

reply

John Huston sitting around BS'ing with Bogart, Truman Capote, Peter Viertel, John Woolf, Robert Morley, and Peter Lorre -- of course its a comedy.

reply

Of course it's a comedy. It's a satire of the "heist thriller" type of movie where a group of criminals is after some McGuffin or another. It's one of the earliest movies I can think of that's so deliberately silly within the context of a heist/espionage type framework.

reply

I wouldn't have thought that this could be described as noir albeit the description given was Comedy Noir. I don't think that it imitates or spoofs noir.

As much as I like offbeat stuff some of the humour in this falls flat for me. I think that humour in this is too individualistic to fit into a view of what comedy was really like in the 1950s generally.

reply