MovieChat Forums > Where the Sidewalk Ends Discussion > Dana Andrews was not a B movie actor

Dana Andrews was not a B movie actor


One of the reviews stated he was a B movie actor. During the 40's and 50's he was in the top tier of actors and productions. Best Years of Our Lives, Laura, Fallen Angel ect..............

reply

Agreed. He may not be a screen legend like Clark Gable, Gary Cooper, or Cary Grant but Dana Andrews was a great actor and played the lead in many classic "A" films.

reply

He was a talented actor who has never really gotten the recognition he deserves. He was not a "B" actor in any sense.

reply

I agree. Dana Andrews was a marvelous actor. He played in many excellent pictures, and I was puzzled when I read that review calling him a B actor. Possibly it was written by someone who wasn't aware of his large volume of A-list movies.

reply

The problem is, because of his alcoholism, he descended to B films in part of the '50s and into the '60s, though, frankly, some of them were pretty good. Also, as good as he is, he s thought of as an actor who had a big career during the war because the stars were away, and sometimes those actors suffer from a certain amount of dismissal by critics.

reply

Right you are and Andrews was absolutely terrific in "The Best Years of Our Lives". I have never forgotten his ability to show, in subtle ways, his characters inner suffering. An excellent actor all around.

Nothing is more beautiful than nothing.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I have loved him in all of his films. Wonderful actor!

"OOO...I'M GON' TELL MAMA!"

reply

well, I haven't read through any of the reviews yet (I just saw it this afternoon for the first time), but if I was to call someone a B movie actor it wouldn't necessarily be an insult. There are lots of cool B movie actors, some of them even with loads of talent who just ended up making mostly B movies. Just like some great directors like Edgar Ulmer and Jacques Tourneur were B movie directors. And speaking of Tourneur, he and Andrews worked together on more than one "B movie" -- 1946's "Canyon Passage" and 1957's "Night of the Demon" (aka "Curse of the Demon"), perhaps others I don't know of. They are both excellent movies but they are also both clearly B movies in my opinion. B movie doesn't always mean Ed Wood or Sam Katzman level of B. But almost certainly both of those films would have been distributed as the lower half of the bill which would make them B movies. I think a lot of the posters in this thread are sort of not realizing that there's a technical distinction there. I would be willing to bet that both "Laura" and "Where the Sidewalk Ends" were actually B movies themselves, although it's possible that they were distributed on the top of the bill based on Tierney's popularity. Still the difference in budget between the Tierney/Andrews films and say the Tierney/Power films is noticeable. Commercially speaking, it's fairly clear that Andrews was not a top star in the 50s, based on the fact that he's usually paired with a more popular female lead who could help sell the movie.

p.s. if anyone seriously doubts that this was a B movie, then why did Fox recycle an old musical score from "Street Scene" instead of having new music written for the film?

Did I not love him, Cooch? MY OWN FLESH I DIDN'T LOVE BETTER!!! But he had to say 'Nooooooooo'

reply

In the forties, Dana Andrews was a solid A-List actor. Starting with supporting work in two Gary Cooper films -- The Westerner (40) and Ball Of Fire (41) -- and then, in 1943, opposite Henry Fonda on Ox-Bow Incident -- Andrews quickly became an above-the-title star. By 1948, Andrews was billed above Henry Fonda in Daisy Kenyon. What killed his career and sent him into B-films was his drinking. He was an alcoholic and in the 1960s managed to conquer his drinking and become a spokesman for groups working to curb alcoholism.

Had he not been an alcoholic, he might well have continued throughout the fifties with terrific films.

Either way, he was a fine actor, and especially wonderful as a Preminger hero. Or, check out his courtroom summation in Elia Kazan's Boomerang. He is aces.

reply

I realize I'm 3 years behind the comment curve here but I agree with your assessment of Dana Andrews. I saw him in the early 60's in Santa Barbara and saw Mr. Andrews gassing up his Lincoln (I remember it seemed to take a while) at a Flying A station and saw him stagger around. Being only a kid I told my mom "that guy looks sick!" She said he was a famous actor and had a "snoot full." (way before 9-1-1 and M.A.D.D. I'm afraid). I'd later see famous people in town like Burl Ives (liked to shop at Ralph's) and Fred MacMurray but nobody schnockered. I also recall reading that, despite his alcoholism, Mr. Andrews was ALWAYS prepared--- knew his lines and was never late to a set... and to his credit he overcame his demons late in life and was very open about it. And in my opinion, Best Years of Our Lives ranks as one of the greatest films ever made, and largely due to his performances (great last line: "I can learn!").

reply

Definitely "Sidewalk" was a B movie and Andrews starred in many B movies. However, he did appear in many A movies earlier in his career. And, even if he is considered a B movie actor, his ACTING was top notch.

reply

The thread consensus seems to be that he was an A-/B+ actor.

reply

"Sidewalk" was not a B film by any stretch. It had an A budget, was directed by a man who only made A films by that time, and had an A cast. Recycling musical scores was common, and not indicative of a film's lower status (even the Mummy used Dracula's opening theme, and both were A films).

reply

"if anyone seriously doubts that this was a B movie, then why did Fox recycle an old musical score from "Street Scene" instead of having new music written for the film?


Recycling film scores was a common practice in Hollywood and not indicative of the quality of the film. Fox recycled the score from These Three in The Razor's Edge a few year later. Surely you don't think the latter was a B movie.



"The night was sultry."

reply

Dana Andrews, like Joseph Cotten, has never really gotten the respect or fame he deserves. Both were great actors who appeared in many, many "A" movies, often in leading roles, and yet neither was ever nominated for a major award and they're nowhere near as well-known as Cary Grant, Clark Gable and the like.

Shame.

"He's already attracted to her. Time and monotony will do the rest."

reply

Absolutely right about Cotton, he has to be one of the most underrated actors ever.

Dana Andrews is also highly underrated.

reply

Right on both counts; excellent actors. Andrews finally has two biographies out on him, both produced within the last three years. I just wish someone would write a bio on John Payne (and Edmond O'Brien).

reply

I agree with everyone that says Dana Andrews was an A-list actor. However, I can understand anybody who saw him first in 'The Frozen Dead' thinking he was a B-lister. But hey, someone who first saw Henry Fonda in "the Swarm" might think the same of him! No offense meant to fans of either movie!

reply

^^Good point, corriganville.

reply

In my opinion, he was a top-notch performer. I loved him in this movie, Laura, The Best Years of Our Lives, Ball of Fire, and a few others.

~~
JimHutton as ElleryQueen: talented hot sexy

reply

[deleted]

We know who the a-list people were: Grant,Wayne,Stuart, Crosby et al. He ranked below them but above a large list of working actors (Reagan,Foster,Scott,Tucker,Murphy et al.).

The film scripts he used to specialize in seemed to drift to that new thing called TV. His career faltered somewhat in the 50's.



reply

TV wasn't new in the fifties. In fact, there is a 1935 movie called Murder by Television.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0026740/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1

~~
JimHutton as ElleryQueen: talented hot sexy

reply

Personally, I think many of the actors of that time were OVERRATED. Clark Gable, Cary Grant, Gary Cooper, and, yes, Dana Andrews. Andrews turned in a few good roles. "Laura" is probably his best film. The ending of "Where the Sidewalk Ends" ruined it for me. The Hayes code sabotages another potentially good film.

reply

With a couple of exceptions, like "The Frozen Dead" and "Hot Rods to Hell" in the mid-1960s, Andrews was by no means a B movie actor. Throughout his long career, he starred and co-starred almost exclusively in first-rate films.

reply