What were Dorian's evil deeds?


I just saw the movie version on public television without commercial interruption and the use of color spliced into the black-and-white film was most effective.

But I am at a loss, never having read Oscar Wilde's book, because my only exposure with the character was, in all places, "The League of Extraordinary Gentleman."

I understand -- at least I think I do -- that the vain Gray was easily influenced with the decadent philosophy of living life to the fullest and giving in to urges.

His path to his own self-destruction in the film was when he corrupted the morals of a young woman he idealized for her purity, chasity (by having sex?)

When he rebuffed her cruelly for not living up to his expectations, he spurned her by letter, paid her off and she committed suicide and he feels guilty.

And so it seems, from what little I can gather from the movie, he embarks on a life of depravity and sin, since his action directly, indirectly caused her death.

But what were the acts, evil deeds he committed in the subsequent years of ageless life? In the movie, it seems like they were only alluded to but not specified.

Maybe they are explained in Wilde's book but if you can help me out with the movie version, I'd appreciate it.

Although this was my only viewing of the Oscar-winning film, I don't get Gray's connection with the scientist he blackmails into disposing the artist's body.

I also don't get his connection with the guy in the seedy pub who draws a caricature of Gray on the table in chalk -- what's their history?

Again, if anyone can fill me in why he was, as was mentioned in the movie, the object of such speculation about his misdeeds, besides looking young, do so.

Thanks.

reply

Whilst I'd have to agree with the other posters, ie it's never specified what he's been up to for 20 years, there are some things mentioned.

1. Alan Campbell had been Dorian's good friend, perhaps romantically linked, and Dorian knew things about Alan which Alan did not want to be known by anyone else. Hence the blackmail, and Alan's suicide.
2. Adrian, in the opium den, had the same ties to Gray as Campbell. Gray had led Adrian to his opium and booze soaked life.

In the book, Dorian breaks up with Sibyl face to face, having never been 'intimate' with her, but she subsequently does indeed kill herself. When he sees the portrait has changed and not he, he thinks 'oh well why not' and carries on with his other sins.

These are largely that he corrupts other young men, often to thier doom, or loss os family / career / status. Women obviously are also used by him in whatever manner he sees fit, and he does a fair amount of opium.

He then murders Basil and blackmails Alan. Doesn't really matter what he did though, any tiny bad thing can play on a person's mind, which for Dorian is his portrait.

Lastly, he was trying to slash the painting to shreds so that he may no longer be reminded of the state of his soul, but the act kills him instead.

There is no more detail in the book, there doesnt need to be. When we are happy we are always good but when we're good we're not always happy? I certainyly dont live my life that way, if I knew a thing would hurt a person, I wouldn't do it - which is Dorian's real sin.

reply

[deleted]

Wilde (about whom I wrote my thesis in 1974) was deeply ambivalent about his own homosexuality, although oddly enough he was less so after his imprisonment for it. But he lived in a far more unforgiving time; the Victorians were terribly hypocritical about all sex. The novel implies that Basil Hallward lusted after Dorian, and that Dorian had an affair with Allan, who assisted in the dissolution by acid of Hallward's body.
Although this film is consistently highly touted, I have always loathed it. Hurd Hatfield looks enbalmed, rather than beautiful, and the young Angela Lansbury, while a fine actress, is wildly miscast as Sybli. In the novel she is rejected by Dorian cruelly when her performance as Juliet in fromt of his friends fails to measure up to his previous assessment of it.
There is a Dan Curtis (of Dark Shadows fame) version of this, made for TV in the 1970s, at the height of the sexual revolution and before the anti-gay backlash engenderd by AIDS in the 1980s which, though a tad overheated, is far more faithful to Wulde's equally overheated but still rather wonderful novel.

reply


Dorian was a hedonist who enjoyed excess. He was obviously bisexual or gay (he seemed to enjoy men and women) but I would never consider that painting marring worthy and I don't think Wilde thought that way either. He did drugs (Opium), he blackmailed Alan Campbell, he committed murder with Basil, he drove people to suicide (and not just Sibyl) as implied in this version. He just was an all around not-nice-guy.




reply

In the movie, they stated that women that used to seek his company would go silent when he entered the room. One lady left a terrible confession after she died. Remember that at this time, Oscar Wilde had been imprisoned for his affair with a noble's son. At this time, anything other than the "missionary" position would have been frowned on, especially if the woman was married. Today, what we don't bat an eye at would have been considered utter depravity at that time. Hope that helps.

reply

I think the reason many people are struggling with the question,"what are the sins Dorian committed?", are that a lot of people today believe there are no sins; to believe in sins means to pass judgement. Very few people in our society deal with this question openly unless they are willing to be lamb basted as a Christian right-wingers. I guess many people believe that "what feels good to you should be okay with me...unless I'm hurting someone else". This is just part of the reason for the difficulty in understanding this question. If people do want to ask the question about Dorian's sins then the idea that Wilde left the door open for the reader to make up their own mind is brilliant. In the days this novel was written, readers didn't need to be "spoon-fed". The reader was able to use critical thinking skills to come to their own conclusion.

reply

I laughed at cafgk's malapropism "lamb basted." Moistening a roasting lamb with butter, drippings, or the like is nothing like the correct word, "lambasted" meaning variously to beat or thrash, or in the context of the sentence, to scold or reprimand. Oscar Wilde might have considered it a sin to publish text that displays personal ignorance. In modern times, that appears to be only a minor misdeed.

On to Dorian's unmentioned sins. In modern Western society, one needs no religious dogma, sexual repression, or homophobia to consider some obvious sins: murder, rape, robbery, assault, battery, knowingly spreading diseases, perjury, fraud, cruelty. Dorian explicitly committed some of these, and implicitly perhaps all of these, maybe multiple times. Sophisticated readers and movie viewers of any time period don't need to be spoon fed to imagine truly evil deeds.

reply

When the book was written in 1890, there were no treatments for syphilis. Yes, it was assumed that someone's evil thoughts would twist the lines of his face and make him look more cynical and bitter; but Dorian Gray was supposedly also guilty of having sex with the lowest prostitutes in London (which would definitely give you syphilis). Untreated syphilis can eventually give you grotesque facial and body sores.

And he was guilty of abusing opium, a drug as addictive as heroin that ruined your looks. If Oscar Wilde had been explicit about these actions, his book would never have been published. So he hinted at them, knowing that his audience of 189 would fully understand them.

reply

"Others are merely hinted at, as when the men in the social clubs whisper behind his back and look on him with scorn, leaving the viewer to imagine the very worst of Dorian."

That was always one of the most horrifying things about Dorian Gray to me--that even after he'd destroyed so many people to the point people would openly shun him, he was never kicked out of polite upper-crust society. Which is worse--a man who persuades others to debauch themselves...or a society that continues to permit him to do so because of his money/breeding?

reply

One subtle reference made in the book is how Dorian would sneak out of his house at night and head down to Blue Gate Fields - an area of London that was notorious for opium dens and brothels.

reply

[deleted]