MovieChat Forums > Laura Discussion > The leading men act REALLY gay

The leading men act REALLY gay


SPOILERS
This movie was a favorite of mine when my mother introduced it to me when I was a child. I watched it recently and realize it's not that well plotted or acted (Tierney is wooden), and the only thing it has going for it is the twist of Laura not being the murder victim, and a haunting theme song. Both Webb and Price seem very gay to me - I don't care if they were gay or not in REAL life, they are totally unbelievable playing heterosexual characters in this film. I would have believed they were in love with each other before being entranced by Laura. All the characters but Laura are despicable. Why would such a nice, lovely woman surround herself with such vipers? Laura's apartment is garish and cluttered with the most awful ruffly lamps, curtains and more (maybe to signify wealth? Was interior design that hideous in the 40s?). Gene Tierney's wardrobe is horrid - stripes, checks, the oddly cut dress she wears at the party, etc. There were stunning fashions in the forties - but her clothing was dowdy, only her great beauty pulled it off. I could go on and on, but bottom line - this movie is highly overrated.

reply

Waldo Lydecker was a bitter queen. "Old world" manners has nothing to do with it.

reply

In real life, Webb was believed to be homosexual. Did that inform his performance (which I think is wonderful)? I don't know. Up until Laura gets involved with other men, one has the sense that she and Waldo were close, but it seems to me that it's more of a platonic relationship, sort of a mentoring/companionship relationship. However, there are a couple of scenes when Waldo is standing close to Laura that there seemed to me to be a kind of unspoken passion there. Also, in real life, Webb was 55 when this movie came out and Tierney was 24. So Waldo could have some unspoken passion for Laura, but perhaps the age difference made it unlikely that it could've been anything other than a friendship. The movie never explores this, though.

reply

Two of the leading men did appear camp.

It's that man again!!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I know this movie is not a documentary, but, in the mid-1940's, the dating pool must have been lacking. WWII had taken the 1A's and many did not return.
I agree that Shelby seemed effete. Waldo, of course.
Maybe the movie should be celebrated for its openness to different types of people. Lydecker wanted to be Laura and helped her succeed in a tough business. (My mother was an art buyer for a prime advertising. When the boys came home, she lost her job. TWO men filled it.) Shelby and the somewhat mascueline Anne went well together.

reply

Nothing funnier than trying to make the viewers actually believe Clifton Webb's character would be in love with a woman.

reply