MovieChat Forums > Man on the Flying Trapeze (1935) Discussion > What did you rate 'The Man on the Flying...

What did you rate 'The Man on the Flying Trapeze' (1935)?


This is first-rate W.C. Fields material that is only flawed by bad process shots and an abrupt ending.

I rated this an 8. What did you rate it? And what do you think of it?


... Justin

reply

I saw this movie for the first time last night, and boy, what a comedy. Second to It's a Gift, this is the funniest Fields-movie I've seen so far; certain scenes crooked me up completely, which doesn't happen too often, no matter how funny a movie I'm watching. Witty, clever and biting dialogue throughout, accompanied by a decent portion of classic slapstick. Another factor which I found to be quite notable was the touch of humanity involved in this film; here, Fields expresses genuine love and affection for his daughter, although this does not interrupt with his well known bad habits and image as a "cheater." I agree that the ending was somewhat abrupt; after the climax with the family argument, I simply expected more. However, after an hour of laughs, this is easily forgiven. I gave this movie a 9.

"Virtue needs some cheaper thrills." - Hobbe

reply

Fields expresses genuine love and affection for his daughter...
It's interesting that two or three Fields films have genuine human warmth between father and daughter. Poppy is probably the first to do it. In fact, the success of Poppy may be the reason that theme carries over to other Fields films.


...Justin

reply

I gave it an 8. There are several Fields' movies that are right up there. "You're Telling Me" is one of the best, almost nudging out "The Bank Dick."

Kathleen Howard needs to be crowned the #1 shrew of the movies. Nora Cecil is a jewel, too. She seemed to be typecast as a gossip or shrew in every bit part she played in so many movies of the thirties.

I love the names of the characters like J.Pinkerton Snoopington in "The Bank Dick" along with Og Oggibly, "sounds like a bubble in a bathtub."

reply

Yeah. Kathleen Howard is the best of the ladies lucky enough to ever be a movie wife to W.C. Fields. One of my favorite scenes from a Fields movie is in It's a Gift where she's going on and on scolding him and he wanders into the next room and her voice gets louder and louder and she says, "Why can't you stay in the room when I'm talking to you? No wonder the whole neighborhood knows all our business!"

And at the beginning of The Man on the Flying Trapeze where she tells him there are burglars singing in the basement and he says "What are they singing?" and she's just flabbergasted that he thinks that is important.

And I also laugh out loud every time I see the bit where she starts reading something by "Gertrude Smoon" (I think that's it) out of the newspaper and they do a Gertrude Stein parody. I adore Gertrude Stein but I think this is funny anyway. (I wonder what Stein thought of it.)

Janet! Donkeys!

reply

6/10



When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

"Things happened."
This film sports one of my favorite Fields'isms. I've occasionally fallen back on that two-word understatement to describe my own mishaps.

Like half of his best material, mumbled and understated, this one slides under the radar unless you're listening close for it.

8/10

||||||
||||||

reply

Swift!

I could probably use that phrase every hour of my life.


...Justin

reply

I'm working my way through a 5-DVD set from the library. Going to skip NEVER GIVE A SUCKER AN EVEN BREAK since I've seen it so many times (and it's my least favorite Fields' feature). Going to finish with my most favoritest, OLD FASHIONED WAY. Would you and your brother like to come over sometime soon?

The guy you met who shows vintage movies at festivals and backyards evidently has a good Fields collection. He's going to do a festival sometime in Ohio; Fields' grand-daughter will be in attendance.

||||||
||||||

reply

Oh, that Ohio festival sounds super-cool... Swift, I'm surprised Never Give a Sucker is your least favorite Fields. Details, details. I have an idea why some people, even Fields fans, would dislike it; but I don't want to assume.

I'll send you a PM about the rest.


...Justin

reply

Oh, it's just that there're too many other people and not enough Fields. Lots of breaks away from the funny stuff to listen to his "niece" sing yet another song ... or the typical bland love story on the side. Folks say the same thing about POPPY, which I'm glad to find had a LOT more Fields in it than I recalled from my childhood viewing.

And the other thing is I've just seen SUCKER too many times (simply because the local affiliates tend to show either that or THE BANK DICK and exclude everything else). But both flicks have fantastic car chases.

I just realized that all of his features fall into one of two categories. Either he's a con artist or a hen-pecked schlub. OLD FASHIONED WAY is my favorite of the first category, and IT'S A GIFT edges out all others for the second type.

One reason why I rank OLD FASHIONED WAY as his best is that you get a good peek at his juggling abilities. It might have been my very first Fields movie when I was in grade school, and my brother and I were laughing at his juggling, assuming he was somehow faking it. (Only later did I discover he was once billed as "world's best juggler". In his vaudeville days he developed his act as silent comedy, so he could travel abroad and perform universally.)
But there's not a slow moment in OFW; no boring romantic interest subplot. Fields dominates almost every scene, but the supporting cast is great including a face-off between him and Baby Leroy.

Did you notice that in MAN ON THE FLYING TRAPEZE, his onscreen secretary was also his offscreen mistress, Carlotta Monti?

||||||
||||||

reply

I didn't even know he had a mistress named Carlotta Monti. Have you been peaking at his biography? I know very little of his off-screen life, except that he was jealous of Chaplin.

I think Never Give a Sucker needs those moments of bland normality because it's easily the weirdest of his films.


...Justin

reply

I first became aware of Carlotta Monti when I was a kid. They made a movie called WC AND ME, which was based on her bio. It starred Rod Steiger and Valerie Perrine, and I've always wanted to see it, except it quickly fell into obscurity and is never broadcast. Must've been pretty forgettable.

I was about 9 when the local affiliate ran a short Fields fest on late-night TV ... ran weekly for a month or so, enough to get me hooked. He shot up in my popularity and I started reading up on his life, but the "unofficial" stuff about Carlotta didn't come out until later.

If comics are an insecure lot, Fields was the worst. Jealous of Chaplin? He was jealous of everyone.
Someone at IMDB once pointed out that Fields forced Shemp Howard to play it totally straight on THE BANK DICK (He came across a bunch of folks on the set convulsed in laughter, gathered around Shemp. Fields pointed out to him, "there's only one funny guy around here, and I'm it.")
And the line about "any man who hates children and animals can't be all bad," is really a reference to vaudeville days ... he hated to follow an animal act or routine with kids, because it was hard to win back the audience.
He and Alison Skipworth made an excellent team in a few movies (SIX OF A KIND, IF I HAD A MILLION), and I sometimes suspect the pair-up didn't continue simply because he wanted to protect his star billing.

||||||
||||||

reply

That's such a contrast to Laurel and Hardy, who were both supremely generous - to each other and to everyone else. Jack Benny was also more than happy to be surrounded by funny people.

I haven't read much about W.C. Fields, but I have read about Keaton. I was happy to learn that it wasn't professional jealousy that lead him to choose bland leading ladies for his films. It was money. Joe Schenck wouldn't give him enough for a proper leading lady.

It looks as if the Rod Steiger movie is not available on DVD. Too bad. I'm sure it's not very good, but I'd still love to see it.


...Justin

reply

Forget it.. Seiger movie is awful.. way over the top.. misleading...
Your not missing anything

reply

Movies like Man on the Flying Trapeze are what the '10' rating is there for.

I give it a '10'!

I also gave 10's to It's a Gift, The Bank Dick and Never Give a Sucker an Even Break.

Janet! Donkeys!

reply

Gave it a 5, but gave International House a 9. This one's just too over the top for me.

reply