The Passion of Joan of Arc vs. Donnie Darko
On one hand, we have one of cinema's all time gripping performances executed a midst the intensity of one of the most beautifully shot and yet jarringly tragic films of all time.
BUT
Donnie Darko was so out there! I mean, what does the ending REALLY mean?
Yeah, I'ma have to go with Donnie Darko. Plus the Smurfette part made me LOL!