That's assuming that there was a soundtrack to be lost to begin with... At most I'd imagine that there was some sort of notations for the live music to be played during screenings. I'd even believe that most screenings during the roadshow through America where done music-less with only the narration.
As for the TD-soundtrack that we now have... I don't think it's all that bad in a movie which is basically a series of text stating they go here and do that, followed by that described scene. A handful of great shots for it's time but mostly a demented travelogue where the imagery didn't quite do the descriptions justice... I almost winceingly laughed at the sight of the dreadful and mighty Cerberus
I admire the pioneering spirit and the expertise it took them to get this far. Some of the multiple exposures and especially the forced perspective of the giants where really awe-inspiring when I think about how limited the toolset was back then. Although in the back of my mind I thought, ten years later or so, they could have made the descriptions so much more justice. Not a fault of the movie-makers, of course. Just a comment from a single modern perspective. I do realize that the simplistic, single tripod master shot, -style was the way to make movies at the time.
I guess the producers of the restoration could have made a more traditional soundtrack for those that aren't into the music they chose, but that would essentially double the budget. And in a niché-market like that of restored hundred year old movies... The budgets aren't that big to begin with... As said, we can always mute the TD-track and maybe sync up some other album. As is so popular to do with Dark Side of the Moon.
reply
share