MovieChat Forums > Jack Lemmon Discussion > Does anyone feel he overacted at times?

Does anyone feel he overacted at times?


Ok, before any fans here start berating me as some troll pariah, I would like to express that i happened to be a fan, and still a fan, of his lifelong work. I liked jack just as much as everyone else here did.He has the ability, with his clear voice and expression to express emotions that most actors can barely even convey without forcing themselves.

But does anyone feel that his acting style today would be considered a bit hammy or stylized by today's methods? I actually would like to see another Jack Lemmon type emerge in our dying Hollywood industry of cookie cutter actors and stars.

However, there were contemporaries of the late and great Mr. Lemmon like Richard Crenna who never quite had the accolades or showcase that he had. Mr. Crenna was every bit as good and appealing as an actor as Lemmon was and never garnered the same popularity.

reply

Tony Curtis on Jack, in 'Some Like it Hot, Me, Marilyn and the Movie': Jack's tempo was faster than that of most actors. He was superkinetic, like he didn't want to get caught. He talked quickly and then suddenly changed speed. Or stopped. This was a great way to emphasize something in a scene. It was so distinctive, so unusual. It became a trademark. Sort of a description of overacting, but you know, it never bothered me, in any of the movies I've seen him in, with the possible exception of Mr. Roberts.


"Did you make coffee...? Make it!"--Cheyenne.

reply

Does anyone feel he overacted at times?

No


Marilyn Monroe: I don't want to be rich. I just want to be wonderful.

reply

Never. Jack Lemmon usually played characters who struggled to come to terms with the world in which he lived, but was essentially a fish out of water. His style of comedy was perfect for that.

reply


He did not overact. He had a way of acting that was really his own, with a lot of energy. But in fact, in all the films I've seen with him, I was amazed by his spontaneity and subtlety. He could express a million things with a tone of his voice-not many people can do that.

" You ain't running this place, Bert, WILLIAMS is!" Sgt Harris

reply


I like his overacting cause its very funny :)

reply

He over acted all the time but in a way that was fun and always watchable.

reply

WHAT is overacting?

Do you stop watching the news because authentic reactions aren't nuanced enough for your sense of theatre?

Jack Lemmon was authentic. If he ever was stylized, it was in stylized pieces like "The Great Race."

Richard Crenna was great too. But Jack Lemmon just did that thing that suited a wide range of films that became classics.

reply

[deleted]

Lemmon's persona was that of a man trying to survive in an insane world. I think his dynamic portrayals suited those characters.

reply

[deleted]