MovieChat Forums > EDavies
avatar

EDavies (41)


Posts


Someone commented on Youtube about the live action and animated. Something to clear things up about Gaston in the new live action remake Thought I'd share something that addresses to all the negativity. I love both this film and the original animated film Emma Watson and Paige O'hara (and her thoughts on the film.) Based on what I've seen on some of the reviews I've now come to a conclusion about the world. View all posts >


Replies


It's because they wanted to add some differences to the live action from the animated film. If they were blonde, then it will be too much of a copy. Nope you're not the only one. I too love Emma Watson as Belle. I was pleasantly surprised by her singing. This was a huge step for her after Harry Potter. Yep. Same here. According to Dan Steven's interview, he and Bill Condon wanted to make the beast more like a human trapped inside a beast. Hence why the Beast has more human features on his face and acts a little more like a human. Fourthly, after Belle gets in trouble with the headmaster for teaching a girl to read, he says "The only children you should concern yourself with are your own" after she said all she wanted was to teach a child to read. In a town like Villenueve, women function as baby makers, especially at the time this film was placed in. Fifthly, Gaston does not take no for an answer. To him, a woman that says no does not actually mean no, she means yes. Finally, after she repeatedly turns him down, he essentially threatens her into a relationship by saying she will end up an spinster begging for scraps that the town will ostracize. Excuse me, sir. Belle did get some dimension to her compared to the animated film. Belle came from a large city Paris, but she and her father had to move to the small village Villenueve, because of the plague that killed her mom. Belle's father was so wracked with grief and guilt for leaving his wife there to die (even though its what she wanted, because she didn't want him and Belle to catch the plague), that he couldn't bring himself to tell Belle what happened to her mother. Also Belle is noted to be a girl who is ahead of her time and different from the village, (examples being reading, and creating the washing machine to help with laundry), which is why the village dislike her since they are so small-minded. Not to mention, Belle is kind to everyone (and animals) despite the fact that everyone is being hostile to her, like Jean and Pere Robert. Also she's very friendly to children, and Belle does not say she wanted to teach a girl to read. She says child. Even though it is plainly clear that only boys go to school in this town. Because the child’s gender does not matter, what matters is that the child is being denied an education. She is not greedy, and asks only for a rose from her father after he asks her what he can bring her from the market. Also, it is blatantly obvious that the “provincial” town is actually a patriarchal town that she does not fit into because she does not subscribe to patriarchal ideas. Now onto Gaston, he is basically patriarchy as a person. For a start, he says at the beginning, “Belle is the most beautiful girl in town, that makes her the best.” Secondly,  He pretends to show an interest in what Belle cares about (books) but when pressed, he cannot say a single book he’s read. This makes it clear he does not actually care about her as a person. Thirdly, he seeks out Belle because it’s “hero time”. Not because he cares about the injustice of her laundry being trashed. After seeing your recent post in your other thread, I apologize for insulting you. To each their own. You got to be trolling. And a hater. You're picking relatively stupid reasons to hate something. And a metacritic score of 39 compared to Disney's live action one's 65? Guess which film is the crappy one now. I prefer the Disney live action film any day. I have seen it five times already, blu ray included, and my love for the Disney live action Beauty and the beast has not changed. So you prefer to judge things by its cover? You cannot judge things by appearances. This is what the film is teaching, and you're ignoring it by judging the characters in the film by their actors being black. Also this is a fantasy fairy tale, not everything has to be real. View all replies >