MovieChat Forums > Girl on the Third Floor (2019) Discussion > Good horror movie. No wokeness.

Good horror movie. No wokeness.


Nice surprise here. The movie is a twisted take on haunted houses. Well done, good photography, and some really good performances, specially C.M.Punk and the woman who plays the minister. The characters are credible. On the negative side, it's not really scary, but it grabs your attention until the very end and both drama and comedy work well.

And what's better: no wokeness.

reply

I wish they fleshed out Punks character a little more. Good monster design though, reminded me of something out of silent hill

reply

This is exactly what sprang to mind when I saw it. It managed to capture that creepy/weird/filthy feel of the game series without being an outright imitation.

reply

YEAH IT WAS A COOL FLICK...WHY DO WE HAVE TO PERPETUATE THE USE OF WORDS LIKE "WOKENESS" THOUGH...

reply

What's worse... why do I have to perpetuate the use of 'haunted hause'? why? why???

reply

How much is Punk in the movie? Is he a key character or obvious he filmed his scenes in a couple days?

reply

He's the central character and appears in almost every shot. He keeps a high level acting during the whole movie.

reply

I'd have to disagree. The "comedy" in the film really isn't funny. The writing is poor, especially some really painful dialogue. Punk, who I was a fan of once upon a time, isn't all that great of an actor. And the movie is, as far as I'm concerned, your typical modern horror film, complete with needless gross out shock moments, jump scares, nonsensical thin plot, face-palm worthy leaps of logic, etc.

As for the no "wokeness", I'd say it would be refreshing to see in a modern film, unfortunately this film has it, subtly and not so subtly. The main character is a stereotypical "evil straight white male", who actually has zero redeeming qualities, he's not likeable, he's not a nice guy, he is a real life "former" scumbag, cheats on his wife, etc. He's seduced by the ghost because he's bad, and "gets what's coming to him". Unfortunately, for no good or compelling reason, his dog and "best friend" also get it, because evil ghost/house.

And then after all that? The now widowed wife doesn't seem to act that bothered by the death of her dog, friend, and husband, and even STAYS in the house that killed them, with her newborn baby. Nonsensical to the extreme. If this is what people consider "good" nowadays, I don't know what to say. But in this man's opinion, it was a fairly bad film. I've certainly seen far worse. But it's just one of many especially poor modern horror films I've seen, most of which, ironically, on Netflix.

reply

Another bigoted asshole to add to my ignore list. Have fun cutting your eyeholes in your pillowcases, Richard.

reply