Yes, how is that NOT her switching the vials???? Are you on crack?
I agree that the shouting might have been difficult to hear for people that were sleeping. But not everybody was asleep at that time, like Harlan says himself to her "make sure they see you getting out and point out the time". So, they both knew that other relatives were still up at that time.
Also, his plan had her come back and impersonate him in his robe, so again, they knew that somebody was gonna see her because they obviously were not sleeping.
So, them being asleep is not a valid reason for not hearing him.
If anything, shouting bye would look a bit strange (like, wouldn't he tell her bye while she's still up), but I meant "shout bye" as in to give a sign that he's still alive (he could have shouted something like "Marta don't forget to bring my book back tomorrow", like anything that you shout at the last minute after someone has just left).
Hey my plan is not bombproof, but it's easy, doable and looks like what anybody would come up with instead of that convoluted bs we see in this movie.
reply
share
FFNogoodnik (770)
4 years ago
Yes, how is that NOT her switching the vials???? Are you on crack?
Well, she picked up the vials. Choose the one with the medicine she wanted to use and used it. That is a perfect description of someone not switching vials. The key is this: The medicine IN the vial is the important thing and not the label on the vial.
To put it another way: You are at the Thrombey family picnic. Ransom has swapped the contents in the mustard and ketchup containers. You ask Marta to pass you the mustard. She looks at the containers and gives you the one with the Yellow stuff in it even though the label says "Ketchup". Are you going to accuse Marta of switching the containers and demand she give you the other one?
reply
share