MovieChat Forums > Star Trek: Picard (2020) Discussion > Why all the phasers hidden around his ho...

Why all the phasers hidden around his home?


This was so stupid when an assassination squad of Romulan secret police invade Picard's home and he and his Romulan house servants dispatch them all with not one but three different phasers concealed under furniture in his living room. Why would Picard have so many deadly weapons all over his home? I know defenders of the show would say, well, he was expecting trouble, but I doubt phasers are covered by the second amendment in his time, so he shouldn't even have them. Also, how does one old man and two house servants turn the tables on an elite Romulan assassination squad and kill them all? And one final thing, they killed five or six people and they don't call the police, so now it looks like they murdered them. Did the servants bury the bodies in the vineyard? The one blonde woman kills the guy and Picard just hands her a glass of wine saying it's alright. This show is so terribly written.

reply

Cos it's NOT Star Trek, no matter how much Abrams and Kurzman want you to think it is.

reply

Yep... aside from them setting it in the future and calling the main character Picard it is more like watching an old John Wayne era western than any Star Trek show... all that's missing now is Picard having a dog that gets killed by the bad guy to really make him anger and want revenge.

reply

The phasers hidden everywhere is the craziest thing i've seen yet in this show. Like Picard's ranch is some old west plantation out in the middle of a desert somewhere. That needs to fend off bandits and corrupt sheriffs at a moments' notice.

I don't know. Now that you can beam anywhere from the whole universe in a split second, maybe security needed to get ratcheted up a hundred notches. Lord knows there's NO security or star bases around planet Earth anymore. You see those orbital shots? Nothing.

Maybe he has to shoot space weasels trying to eat his grapes.

reply

His ENTIRE ESTATE might also be some kind of an ELABORATE HOLOGRAM.

Because in the COMIC BOOK that was released as a BACKSTORY to the PICARD STORY he was also ARRESTED by the ROMULANS and placed into PRISON.

So for all we know he could still be IN PRISON where the ROMULANS are MANIPULATING his MIND and making him think he's been living on the FAMILY FARM for 14 YEARS when he has NOT BEEN.

RIKER also went through something SIMILAR to this when some ALIENS also messed around with his mind. And it also happened to him not just one time but TWO TIMES.

So the FANATICS that attacked the place might also be ROMULANS who wanted to KILL HIM (while he's being PROTECTED by other ROMULANS who are his PRISON GUARDS who want to keep him ALIVE so they can try to learn more about the SECRETS of the FEDERATION).

Note the way COMMANDER OH is also pissed off at LT. RIZZO because she let DAHJ DIE before they could INTEROGATE her.

So naturally they'd also want to MILK PICARD for INFO about the FEDERATION the same way as they wanted to get the other INFO from DAHJ.

A situation like that would also explain the LOOK of COMPLETE SURPRISE that we see on the face of LARIS as she watches the TV INTERVIEW where PICARD defends the need to RESCUE the ROMULANS even though they were also their ENEMIES.

Why are people in such a BIG HURRY to RUSH to JUDGEMENT???

Why not just BE PATIENT and SIT back, RELAX, and wait for the story to UNFOLD itself???

Ever since we began using SOCIAL MEDIA sites It's as if the ENTIRE POPULATION has developed some kind of ATTENTION DEFICICT DISORDER.

And it feels like being on a LONG ROAD TRIP with a bunch of BRATS in the BACK SEAT who keep PESTERING you by saying:

ARE WE THERE YET???






reply

Here's part of a REVIEW of Ep. 3 that reveals how LARIS is most likely the person who STASHED and HIDES all of the WEAPONS in different places around the ESTATE:

https://www.space.com/star-trek-picard-episode-3-review.html

QUOTE:


suddenly, from nowhere, a Tal Shiar spec ops team assaults the château. This has been skillfully set up and catches you totally by surprise. Moreover, the combat is well choreographed as Laris steals the show. She ducks, dives and dodges incoming fire, while simultaneously, single-handedly, taking out half the squad. Picard and Zhaban do their bit too, but Laris is in her element. A beautiful extra touch is that a handphaser is secretly hidden under almost every desk and table in the lounge; someone — probably Laris — is clearly a firm believer in being prepared.

END QUOTE


Which also MAKES SENSE with her being a former member of the TAL SHIAR which would probably also make her someone who KNOWS how to BE PREPARED when TROUBLE shows up.

And of course she'd also KNOW TROUBLE was on the WAY with the DEATH of DAHJ taking place when PICARD was with her and then finding out how someone had also ERASED all traces that he'd been with her from the VIDEO.





reply

My guess is at least some of the SCENES that we see are taking place inside of a HOLODECK.

NOTE the way PICARD is dressed when he does the TV INTERVIEW in Ep 1 and compare it to the way he's dressed when he goes to visit the ADMIRAL at STAR FLEET.

BIG DIFFERENCE!!!

One SUIT is OLD FASHIONED like something PICARD would wear when he was PRETENDING to be the DETECTIVE DIXON HILL inside of the HOLODECK in TNG.

The other SUIT is much more MODERN LOOKING.

PLUS we also see an OLD FASHIONED HAT hanging on the HAT RACK as PICARD GAZES at himself in the MIRROR right before he does the TV INTERVIEW.

And it also looks like it's sitting ON TOP of his HEAD as it sits there on the HAT RACK in the BACKGROUND.

PLUS the PREVIEW CLIP for EP. 4 also has PICARD wearing an OLD FASHIONED looking WHITE SUIT with a WHITE HAT that looks very much like the other HAT that we see HANGING UP on the HAT RACK in the BACKGROUND as he gazes at himself in the MIRROR.

And that means the show MAY HAVE BEEN WRITTEN so that one DOESN'T REALIZE what's REAL and WHAT IS NOT REAL.

And that's also INCLUDES NOT KNOWING that DAHJ wasn't REALLY HUMAN.

And it may also include NOT KNOWING AGNUS or the DR. J character is also a SYNTH (like DAHJ) which could also explain why she's able to be such a good SHOT with the weapon.

And it may also include NOT KNOWING that the PILOT is also a HOLOGRAM (like the other DOC was in VOYAGER) which would also explain the reason why he dismissed his TWIN who is tending to his WOUND and then sits there with the PIECE of METAL still sticking into his shoulder .

As you may recall, the HOLOGRAPHIC DOC from VOYAGER was also GIVEN the SAME LEGAL STATUS as DATA had after his TRIAL. Meaning BOTH of them were given the SAME LEGAL STATUS any other HUMAN had.

So perhaps what you see as being BAD WRITING may also be your INABILITY to SEE what's happening properly???

reply

What's with the intermittent caps?

reply

I think I might have an explanation for it.

Because of the kind of man Picard was, and what he did as a Starfleet captain, being the hero leading a whole band of heroes, he gained quite a few enemies over the years. I have no doubt he made sure any home he lived in had good security, due to people coming after him, possibly for revenge. That would include things like perimeter fences and alarms, a force field over the house, and hidden compartments in furniture or walls, where guns or other weapons could be stored, but only he and his housemates would know about it. I've seen it many times in both literature, tv shows, and movies, where a powerful person (even if they aren't active in world-changing stuff) would go out of their way to protect themselves and their families in their own home, due to risks they knew might happen.

Becoming close friends with two ex-Tal Shiar Romulan operatives would also factor into making his house extra secure. I mean, the couple living with him weren't just caretakers. They were Picard's unofficial bodyguards. They remembered how paranoid and distrusting Romulan society was under the original oppressive empire, before the Hobus disaster. Soji mentioning the False Front Door was very telling about Romulan society too.

I would like to point out that the world of the 24th century is very different from our own. They don't have the same kind of laws or views on things we Americans cherish in the 21st century, such as being allowed to own guns. Using current laws to describe how a civilization in the future conducts itself, particularly after World War III and fighting various alien races that threatened the earth over the centuries; doesn't make much sense if you think about it.

reply

36,000 gun deaths per year in the USA is really something to cherish.

reply