MovieChat Forums > Midsommar (2019) Discussion > 7.2? 7.2??? what the fuck? oh so this is...

7.2? 7.2??? what the fuck? oh so this is just a barely above average film??? this is a travesty!


one of the most impactful, powerful, mesmerizing, meaningful, harrowing, experience films ever made and it's at just 7.2??? it should be at at the very least 9.0. i can count only around 20 films that have ever impacted me as much as this film. that's how rare great this film is. it's a masterpiece.

reply

Solid 6...ehh maybe a 5. I'm being too generous.

reply

I think 5 is right where you need to be on this film.

Hey Dave, what's with the monkeys and that big stone?

reply

They broke the remote control. Happens.

reply

Thanks, I knew I had to go to the source for an explanation. Not sure even Kubrick knew that.

reply

This was the dawn of touchscreen.

reply

Agreed

reply

THATS HIGHER THAN I WOULD GIVE IT...THE FILM OBVIOUSLY CONNECTS WITH YOU THOUGH..THATS COOL..A LOT OF MOVIES I LIKE GET LOW SCORES OR SHREDDED UP ON THE BOARDS...JUST MAKES YOU APPRECIATE THEM MORE.

reply

but you know there's a right answer here. there is a right and wrong answer to is this a great film. it's technically provable this is a great film. this film has so much more great things in it than 99% of American films made in the last 20 years.

there are great films that are ordinary in their execution and qualities and merits and there are films like this film which defy explanation and classification because they have high artistic ambition and they deliver in every single way exceptional filmmaking. this is an experience film which 99% of Hollywood films of all time aren't.

reply

I think it would be all but impossible to come to this judgement if you've seen The Wicker Man first.

reply

and it just makes you realize how stupid people are. the people who can't connect or understand or like films that have depth and meaning about life and the human condition, religion, family which this film delves into.

reply

i agree with luke. those who don't get this movie are dumber than a box of rocks.

reply

THOSE WHO EQUATE THEIR OPINIONS AS KNOWN FACT ARE DUMBER THAN THAT SAME BOX,MINUS THE ROCKS.

reply

stop yelling at me (cry baby).

reply

SAYS THE GUY CRYING FOR ME TO "STOP YELLING"...YOU FUNNY.

reply

stay at the kids' table, and go suck on your pacifier cry baby. you're not ready for the big time yet.

reply

I like this movie quite a bit but understand why others may not care for it as much. Still I can like and even respect people who's OPINION differs from mine. See how easy that is?

reply

I IMAGINE YOU BELIEVE THAT TO BE FUNNY OR SOMETHING CLOSE TO IT...IN REALITY YOUR COMMENTS PAINT A SAD,JUVENILE PORTRAIT OF YOURSELF...YOU MADE ME FEEL BAD FOR YOU...SHAME.

reply

stop whining crybaby. you couldn't appreciate one of the best movies made in the last decade, and that makes you an infant minded fool. suck it, and stfu.

reply

LOL you are one of the most pretentious posters I've seen on these boards in a while (and that's saying something). But you top it off with mindless insults like "suck it" and "stfu"...that is sad. Kowalski is one of the coolest people on these boards and he respectfully offered a differing opinion...you don't tell people like that to stfu.

reply

crybabies

reply

You're the one who is so fragile you can't handle someone with a different opinion...don't think we're the ones crying here...

reply

https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-5k9x8g/images/stencil/1000x1000/products/155/457/allens_naturally_cloth_diaper_safe_detergent_stop_pacifier_-_Copy__81983.1531229243.jpg?c=2

reply

Dude I wouldn't click on a link provided by you if my life depended on it.

reply

^^^^^
then i'll give a caption instead:
baby sucking pacifier

reply

LMAO AT YOU FOR PROVIDING THAT LINK...WOW.

reply

you crybabies need to suck it real bad. get the pacifiers out, these two don't know how to shut the hell up!

reply

You're a lunatic and you've been owned.

reply

oh look, another crybaby! go cry in the corner crybaby!

reply

Don't let the doorknob hit ya...

reply

don't let your boyfriend's nutsack hit ya...

reply

You may want to talk someone about your gay fixation.

reply

You may want to talk to someone about how to take the butt-plug outta your rear, and use it for a pacifier.

reply

Hows elementary school going, little fella?

reply

ok boomer

reply

Wow! Did you just come up with that, junior? I'm amazed by your cleverness!

reply

THE IMPOTANT RAGE IS STRONG IN YOU.

reply

^^^^^^
https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/media/images/52272000/gif/_52272673_crying-baby.gif

reply

I GIVE YOU CREDIT...YOU STARTED WITH CRYBABY AND YOU HAVE MANAGED TO MAINTAIN THAT THEME THROUGHOUT,REGARDLESS OF WHAT IT IMPLIES ABOUT YOURSELF.

reply

i give you credit: you're just like all the rest of the crybabies that whine about Midsommar.

reply

ILL GIVE YOU 100 BUCKS IF YOU CAN POST 3 WORDS OF MINE THAT QUALIFY AS "WHINING ABOUT MIDSOMMAR"

reply

you started whining as soon as i left a comment. does that count? keep your money, i don't want it.

reply

i agree with luke. those who don't get this movie are dumber than a box of rocks


Your first comment was calling people who disagreed with you dumb...

reply

NO.IT DOESNT COUNT,AS IT DOES NOT ILLUSTRATE ANYTHING OTHER THAN YOUR LIMITED READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS...

reply

it is YOU that cannot read. i said those who didn't get the movie were dumb. midsommar's greatness has nothing to do with what i think of it.

reply

"i said those who didn't get the movie were dumb."



HOW OLD WERE YOU WHEN THEY DIAGNOSED YOU?

reply

He's all yours dude, not worth anymore of my time (or yours really).

reply

LOL!
Incidentally what did you think of Hereditary?

reply

I LIKED HEREDITARY MORE THAN I LIKED MIDSOMMAR.NEITHER ARE MY FAVORITE FLICK,BUT BOTH WERE ENTERTAINING.

reply

I liked them both quite a bit but also liked Hereditary more. Weird how we can feel differently about these movies yet still be civil toward each other...it's as if we're adults or something..,

reply

YEAH...YOU GET A LITTLE OLDER AND REALIZE ALL YOUR EFFORTS TO BE THE COOLEST ASSHOLE IN THE ROOM ALWAYS CAME OFF MORE ASSHOLE THAN COOL.

reply

more whining? oh look! an ignore button. that's one way to shut you crybabies up!

reply

LMAO.GOOD FOR YOU.

reply

Well said.

reply

ignored.

reply

Oh no...you mean I don't get to have anymore of these scintillating conversations with you? First thing you've said that I've liked :)

reply

solid 6 . four

reply

Most highly acclaimed modern indie horror films have suprisingly low ratings. It Follows has a 6.8, The Witch has a 6.9, and Hereditary has a 7.2 as well. It’s strange because every other critical website lists these films with bery high ratings, but IMDb sugget theyre just average, maybe slightly above average but nothing special.

reply

I hear you. It was extremely well acted but I wonder if it got passed by how messed up the movie was LOL.


All kidding aside, it probably got passed up since it did not meet any agenda checks. There was no transgenderism preached, there was no SJW overtone, and there was no homosexual, transgender, or some other love scene that is all but required. Oh....they didn't bash Trump and hate on white people. That is what most likely kept them out of the awards.

reply

It is IMDB, what do you want from them? We know it is so much better than that.

reply

i mean can you remember the last film that made you feel that hypnotized, mesmerized, and transported emotionally and physically to an altered state?

reply

Loved it. One of the best movies in years.

reply

i can imagine the movie worked in theaters, but rewatch it at home, its rather bland and leads nowhere 5/10

reply

Hmmm, I've watched it a few times from home and I still find it entertaining

reply

7.2 is a very good rating. Not great. Very Good.

reply

I gave it a 9 - it was a very intense experience

I think a lot of people dont have the patience for a slow movie that is based on atmosphere anymore and if it makes them feel uneasy they might rate it badly

But who cares - it shouldnt affect you that a lot of ppl cant see its beauty
Its just a bit sad for the producers

reply

It was a good film i suppose, i think peoples standards are quite low nowadays because 90 percent of films are cut and paste

If you have seen Rosmary's Baby and the Wicker man and films or that ilk then Midsommer looks like a decent film inspired by those but they did it better in my opinion, but if you are comparing it to the Conjuring and Paranormal Activity people probably think it's a Masterpiece

But if we are talking about low IMDB scores then Kill List has a 6.4 and that film is much better than Midsommer and every other Horror for that matter but i think that it was a bit to disturbing for most people and they can't handle it and are put off, but they miss the genius, same as Salo it's actually a very clever film but disregarded as shock porn

My new favourite Imdb score is between 6.2 and 6.7 for some reason they seem to be the best films just divisive enough to put off the tourists whilst not veering into atrocious

Back to Midsommer it was ok but don't get to carried away, the male characters were your typical horror douches and it had that Hollywood twang throughout, they kept doing that annoying thing when anyone brought up that this is fucking weird we should leave, they dismiss it and act blind(Hack) even it it is a cut above the rest of the crap nowaday's

6.9 is a fair score

reply