Anyone see this?


Is it good?

reply

I read in a review that the idea was to make a feminist version of X-Files.

You can imagine the rest.

reply

[deleted]

It is from a pretty fun book from 2012..not before PC but before the PC extreme mania... but I don't know yet what they've done with it.
It does seem from reviews that it lacks the books magic.

reply

PC tropes appeared in books way earlier than in movies. In books, you can notice how they started to appear in early 90s, becoming more and more common during the 2000s. Movies had a 10 years delay.

And that still happens. 'Diversity / Feminism' has become common in movie awards, but you still see white males here and there. In the Hugo Awards (the most important scifi writing awards), this years, from short story to novel, 22 out of 24 candidates are women. Males have been banned in practice.

reply

SPOILERS It’s a hell of a lot more like Total Recall meets Push than it is The X-Files. The protagonist has Powers, and so do her peers. Myfanwy (rhymes with Tiffany) works for a branch of British Intelligence and someone has wiped her memory, apparently in the course of her killing 8 men without laying a hand on them. She knew in advance she would lose her memory and left behind instructions for her tabula rasa self. To me, this has the potential to remain a bland place-holder of a series, or blossom of into something kinda good. For one thing, it has both Olivia Munn and Joely Richardson in The cast, and I like them both. For another, 3 siblings with the family name Gestalt work at the agency, and they seem to share an interesting hive intelligence. For yet another, there was one really good line. Munn is a US agent dispatched to London because apparently an American agent was one of the guys Myfanwy bumped off (by driving his jawbone into his carotid artery). Munn asks Eliza Gestalt for more access to the English investigation, and Eliza replies, “No. I’m sorry.” Munn says, “That doesn’t sound sincere.” Olivia has good comic timing, and I hope The Rook makes use of it. Also, great legs.

reply

Not getting good reviews. https://screenrant.com/the-rook-series-premiere-review-starz-olivia-munn/

reply

ok thanks,i'll skip it then.

reply

It premieres tonight. We’ll find out then.

reply

I tried reading the book few years ago but dropped it after 20 pages or so. I've made almost to the and of the 1st episode and am dropping this one too.
It's dull.

reply

The first episode was okay, not great.

Watchable, though - I'll give it a chance for now. Like R_Kane said, this can develop into something truly worthwhile - there hasn't been anything outright bad about it yet.

reply

I just finished 1.5, and it improves with each episode. I’d like stronger casting, though I like Richardson and Munn, but that’s probably a decision effected by budget. What I really like is how the narrative keeps opening up, with developments that surprise but also make sense, not just pulled out of someone’s butt as a “twist.” There is a very strong science-fiction element, but—thank goodness—it lacks a comic-book feel. It’s the kind of show that rewards you for paying attention.

reply