MovieChat Forums > Chernobyl Discussion > The Reason They Fictionalize Nuclear Dis...

The Reason They Fictionalize Nuclear Disasters Like Chernobyl Is Because They Kill So Few People


https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/05/09/the-reason-they-fictionalize-nuclear-disasters-like-chernobyl-is-because-they-kill-so-few-people/

In my research, I have come to see the entertainment industry as a major factor behind popular fears of nuclear.

Movies like “China Syndrome” (US - 1979), “Die Wolke” (Germany - 2006) and “Pandora” (South Korea - 2016) all contributed to the halting of nuclear plant construction, and the burning of fossil fuels instead.
__

In the first episode of “Chernobyl” the nuclear reactor explodes, blows the top off the building, and catches on fire. The plant workers vomit, their faces turn red, and several appear to die.

We see a plant worker in his twenties hold open a door to the reactor hall and various parts of his body start to bleed. He rescues a comrade with a red, blistered, and bloody face, and appears to leave him for dead in a hall. Later we see the man slumped over and smoking what appears to be his last cigarette.

Later, the plant manager who was in denial about the accident becomes violently ill after he learns the true scale of the disaster. As he leaves for the hospital, we see a fireman who is carrying a body on a stretcher collapse and drop the body.

I was left thinking that dozens of workers and firefighters were immediately killed, but according to the official United Nations report (p. 66) on the accident, just two workers, not dozens, or hundreds, were killed within a few hours of the explosion.
__

Chernobyl’s total death toll is small compared to other famous disasters. According to the United Nations, 28 first responders died a few weeks after the accident, and since then 19 died for ”various reasons” including tuberculosis, cirrhosis of the liver, heart attacks, and trauma. The U.N. concluded that “the assignment of radiation as the cause of death has become less clear.”

reply

Stupid post, upwards of 1 million people have died because of Chernobyl.

reply

The official Soviet (now Russian) figure is 31. However the true estimate of deaths from radiation since then range from as low as 4000 to as high as 100,000. And it's not fictional films that halt nuclear power, it's reality. Aside from Chernobyl, there were previous USSR accidents, such as the 1957 one, and a later one at Chernobyl (yes, they kept it operating until 2000!) . And just when they pretended things were okay again Fukushima happened. Looks like your industry is hitting 0 for 5! Is sticking with fossil fuels the answer? Of course not! Clean renewables is.

reply

You're basically mistaken about Chernobyl. It does not give the impression of lots of people being killed immediately by the accident. It shows some of the firemen and plant workers getting ill within hours of being exposed to massive doses of radiation. Which is entirely accurate.

reply

So you are saying that big oil sabotaged the plant?

reply

It's the same with nuclear bombs.

reply