MovieChat Forums > Tenet (2020) Discussion > This had better be better than Dunkirk

This had better be better than Dunkirk


Christopher Nolan is my all time favorite director but man did he drop the ball with Dunkirk. Hopefully he can bounce back with Tenet, having an actual plot would be a good place to start.

reply

What do you mean? Dunkirk was great!

reply

I also loved Dunkirk, but know many people had an issue with the different timeframes. Really, it was not difficult to follow once you knew what was happening...there were even captions on screen when it switched timeframes to help.

But the problem is the benchmark for Dunkirk movies is the 1950s version with John Mills, and most people seemed to expect a similar type of movie, with plenty of heroism and stiff upper lip etc.

But honestly...Nolan is clearly not that kind of director. He has dabbled with different timeframes in his movies before...so why would people expect a conventional movie from him?

reply

I actually didn't have a problem with the different time frames, I actually found it kind of fun to match them up to each other when one time frame would catch up to another one.

My problem is the entire film is nothing but action sequences, it was all spectacle yet no substance. One thing that makes Nolan's films so great is they have really strong characters and Dunkirk just didn't have that at all, when one of your top billed actors is credited as "shivering soldier" you know you have problems. Again Dunkirk is very well done in terms of visual and sound effects but there is absolutely nothing under the surface and that was a huge disappointment considering Nolan had just come off of what I think are his best two movies: The Dark Knight Rises and Interstellar.

reply

Interstellar is one of his best movies? That's weird to read. I think it is one of his worst. It's certainly below The Prestige, Inception, TDK, Batman Begins and Memento.

reply

Interstellar to me is his second best, (TDKR is his best). Interstellar was almost the perfect movie. I don't know why but Nolan has put out two of his weakest films recently with Dunkirk and Tenet, my problem with both of them are the under developed characters which is a problem that none of his previous films had. He seems to be going more for the spectacle than the story which is odd because he's such a great filmmaker. Also he needs to stop casting Kenneth Branagh, I have never liked him.

reply

YEAH..DUNKIRK IS DIFFICULT.SO WORTH THE WORK THOUGH...AMAZING FLICK.

reply

Does he deliberately pick his titles so you have no idea what the movie is about? Feels like a theme with him.

reply

Sorry mate, but Dunkirk is a masterpiece imo. I can see why some might not like it as it's not about the characters but the event itself and it was a nice change of pace.

reply

Again it was very good visually and the sound effects were top notch (I would actually say that the technical Oscars it won it deserved) but storywise there is absolutely nothing under the surface and that is something Nolan is very well known for which is why Dunkirk was a disappointment. It takes more than create visuals and realistic sound effects to make a good film. If you want to watch a good War movie I'd suggest sticking with Apocalypse Now, Platoon or Saving Private Ryan.

reply

Same, same, same

Love Nolan and I’m excited to see this movie is coming. But so disappointed with Dunkirk. I think you’re description nailed it. Not BAD or inept or cringeworthy just lacking in substance. This looks like it should be closer to his other films tho

reply

I agree... It is my least favorite Nolan flick... I saw it in IMAX and it is a masterpeice in all the technical areas... but I to was missing interesting characters, story etc.

I know it is based on actual events but that doesn't usually stop Hollywood from adding some juice to the story...

I do recommend you see it... but expect a beatiful shot documentary... nothing more...

reply

dunkirk was his second best and tenet is his second worst. INVERSION

reply

Dunkirk was his weakest definitely, Tenet is down there but was better than Dunkirk.

reply

[deleted]

Your concession is accepted.

reply

[deleted]

Later potpan

reply

[deleted]

Nolan fanboys hate Dunkirk because it doesn't have any twists. "I wAsn'T MinDBlowN".

reply

Dunkirk doesn't have any plot-holes for fanboys to fill up with fanwank to show their superiority.

reply