MovieChat Forums > Underwater (2020) Discussion > Looks terrible, I'd rather watch The Aby...

Looks terrible, I'd rather watch The Abyss again.


This is one of those horror movies masquerading as science fiction that is so stupid it is not even worth thinking about. At 7 miles down the pressure would be so incredibly enormous that if you had so much as a small leak if would rip your habit to shreds and fill up the inside in minutes. I don't think they will ever be able to manufacture suits that can go out in such huge pressure ... like trying to make a suit that will protect you on the surface of the sun ... some things are just impossible and probably always will be.

reply

If air pressure inside is similar to that of outside the suit would just be fine. If the pressure was equal on both sides, even a very thin layer of glass would work.

Of course, to avoid oxygen and nitrogen poisoning at higher air pressures, they have to change air mixtures, and even then, our current record is 70 atmospheres. 7 miles down is over 1000 atmospheres. Very high pressure gasses also have other problems like corrosiveness and thermal superconductivity, but those are well beyond my knowledge.

On the other hand, humans have descended to the trench as early as the 60's, so in the future, it may be possible to come up with very tough materials that can withstand the +1000 atms of pressure difference and be compact enough to make into a suit.

reply

The submersibles have always been very strong on the outside to resist the crushing pressures, and normal atmospheric pressure inside. Movies like this are just silly.

reply

No they are not. You just want them to be, for whatever reason.

reply

They are demonstrably silly, and both of us proved it. What is the point to have a movie based on a technology that could not exist? Star Trek is more realistic. Why are you being a horse's you know what about it anyway?

reply

A movie is an interpretation of reality. It is very difficult to say whether warp drives or replicators or very tough diving suits are more realistic. As long as it doesn't contradict in universe rules, i'm fine with it. Maybe they are breathing an air with 1000 atms of pressure, like, with 0,02% oxygen or whatever.

I'm sorry if i came off as rude, i was brainstorming about various possible explanations.

reply

who cares about details like that - I know ppl like you - who cant enjoy anything because theyre always searching for tiniest plothole or that "impossible" thing .. just be quiet and let me enjoy the movie.

apparently in the universe of "Underwater" these suits can withstand 1000 atmospheres and thats all I need to know

reply

I know children like you.

reply

truth hurts doesnt it xD

reply

I'll probably rent it at some point, but I'm a sucker for this kind of movie. Even the bad ones.

reply