Smurf vs jemma

I hate Smurf and find Ellen Barkin just passable in the role. Average out all of Barkin's roles going back 35 years and compare them to Katey's then I would have to give the edge to Barkin. KS has seen much more work in her career because she is more adaptable to the material. As far as character against character in a street fight the edge goes to Smurf.