MovieChat Forums > This Is Us (2016) Discussion > What actress would you have picked to pl...

What actress would you have picked to play older Rebecca?


I love the show and Mandy Moore, but I don't buy her a a sixty- something woman. Frances Conroy, Frances Fisher or Swoosie Kurtz came to mind. Someone else suggested Diane Keaton. I also think that Sally Field would have been good.

reply

Out of those you mentioned, I'd go with Sally Field.

reply

Sally Field, Swoozie looks a scarecrow these days.

reply

She always did .

reply

Sally Field is a good choice except she's way too short. I think MM is doing a decent job as the older version of herself.

reply

Sally Field too short? But surely you know that lots of people lose some height as they get older ? I too had the same thought about her being on the short side.

reply

But surely you know that lots of people lose some height as they get older ?


MM is almost 5'10. Sally Field is listed at 5'3. No one loses 6-7 inches unless part of their legs are amputated, which is why I said she was too short.

reply

I was half-kidding about Sally Field, knowing the height would be an issue. Did not realize MM was 5'10"....have noticed that she and Jack are about the same height, sometimes she even looks a little taller.

reply

I dunno. I don't really like the older version of Moore's character. Moore shows less emotion and it makes Rebecca seem too reserved in comparison to her younger self.

reply

Jaclyn Smith

reply

I think Mandy Moore is doing a fine job.

Weirdly enough, I find the actor who plays Miguel more believable as the older Miguel than the Miguel he's playing at his own age lol

reply

Me too! Lol

reply

Sally Field is the only one who would resemble her, but too short. I think they kept it at Mandy Moore because of the back & forth sequences. She's already an adult in the flashbacks. Whereas, with the kids, it's easier to change actors because their still growing.

reply

Phylicia Rashad would have been a perfect choice to play an older Rebecca. She was awesome in the Cosby Show and is the right age to play the character in 2016/2017.

reply

LOL. Phylicia Rashad is great, but she also happens to be black. Which Rebecca is not.

reply

lol I was about to say the same thing

reply

Jo Beth Williams, Anne Archer, Linda Gray, and/or Sigourney Weaver...she's tall like Mandy!

HA, you could dye Susan Sullivan's hair brown and pair her with Jon Huertas...it would be a Castle reunion! ;-)

reply

I think Mandy is doing a great job, but they need to make her look much older. She was 30 when the triplets were born, they're now 36, so she's at least 66.

reply

They definitely need to make Mandy look older. She looks like she's playing her older sister. T, she is a beautiful woman, and I can see Rebecca being vain and doing stuff to keep herself youthful. Hair dyeing, botox, etc. So her playing a 66 year old woman that can pass for early-mid 50s ain't too far fetched

reply