MovieChat Forums > This Is Us (2016) Discussion > Randall the sanctimonious martyr/victim/...

Randall the sanctimonious martyr/victim/saint


Seriously - is there a reason the black guy is the only one of the children who isn't flawed? It reminds me of 60s TV where the black characters had to be these perfect cardboard cutouts, and weren't allowed to have nuances.

reply

He's not flawed??

reply

There were a lot of responses from the old board about this, but no,Randall definitely isn't a saint--he's got problems like anybody else---he just knows how to cover them up better. I just saw a re-run (which I missed the first time) in which after Randall has to come vouch for his biological father, William, who's been stopped by a police officer,and asked for ID while simply walking through Randall's high class neighborhood. they go shopping. While they're talking about what just happened to William, Randall explains to him that being a black man having been raised in a white household and thriving in a white environment has not shielded him from having to deal with subtle racism on some levels. He says that he has to pick his battles carefully in terms of how he chooses to deal with the little racial microaggressions directed at him, which is the only thing keeping him from snapping on white folks about it. Also, he and his brother Kevin didn't get along with each other, because Kevin resented the attention Randall got for being an adopted child having to adjust to their environment. And as adults, they still hadn't gotten over their issues with each other. They both had that big blow-up in the middle of a street one night and fought each other,and a while afterward, were able to forge some kind of relationship with each other.

Also, Randall mentions in one episode, he felt as the only black child in the family, and being adopted, that he always felt pressured to be the together one, so that he wouldn't disappoint his family. So,no, he's nowhere near perfect---i think that he's clearly more mature than either Kevin or Kate, but he's definitely learned to buck up and deal with his problems instead of letting them hold him him back to the extent that they do. Both Kevin and Kate got on my nerves at times with their whining about this and that all the time. They both need a swift kick in the a** in my opinion.

reply

I also love how the show deals realistically and honestly with the issues black people have to deal with concerning racism every now and then--I'm thinking there must be some black writers on the show's writing staff (that probably also explains that wonderfully moving episode where Jack takes a young Randall to an Afrocentric martial arts school, and participates in the warm-up with him--that was too beautiful,and it definitely gave me "the feels" as some other folks would say.) The school itself is based on an actually martial arts school in Detroit,btw, and being from Detroit, that was cool to see.

reply