MovieChat Forums > Wind River (2017) Discussion > Wind River aka Old White Tough Guys Rule

Wind River aka Old White Tough Guys Rule


Man, lucky the Native Americans and that ridiculously inept female FBI agent had a tough, super capable, middle-aged white guy to look after them.

I'd say Taylor Sheridan really needs a new schtick, but he keeps getting award nominations for this one-note dreck.

reply

Old tough white guys do rule, glad you are able to comprehend that..

reply

Why are you so glad?

reply

Haha!!!

reply

Tough old white guys are just plain superior. You better believe it, son.

reply

I understand your point. Although this is generally a pretty good film; it does endorse white masculinity. I really wish Corey had been a Native American man, instead of another "white savior" trope.

reply

Should films not "endorse white masculinity?"

reply

It's not that they should or shouldn't (my favorite action films display white masculinity); I'm simply pointing out the fact that it does so. For a movie that claims to sympathize with Native Americans, I find it contradictory that the hero is another white savior character. Corey married a native woman - Natalie's boyfriend is a 40 year old white dude - Seeing Corey clobber two native guys in the face with a shovel, then kick one of them in the face while he's down. I really wish Adam Beach had been cast as the male protagonist instead.

reply

I remember reading an interview with Taylor Sheridan a while back where he addressed this point head on, and he said he made the protagonist a white guy because he only felt qualified to write from a white person's perspective. Even though he has spent a lot of time on reservations, he didn't feel like it was appropriate to write a story with a native character as the lead, when he's never actually lived that life.

I wish I could find the interview but it was ages ago now when I read it.

reply

What a bigot you are! Ya know, politicians & the left have made it perfectly acceptable to be a bigot nowadays. It's sick. White this, white that. Why are you even bringing that up? The race of the character somehow offended you? That is utterly ridiculous!

reply

@BrunoAntony: so nice of you to show us all what a racist p.o.s you are. Well done.

reply