MovieChat Forums > American Gothic (2016) Discussion > Congrats to those who guessed correctly....

Congrats to those who guessed correctly... (spoilers)

posted 8 years ago by KellyKeybored
2 replies | jump to latest

Round of applause to RIPLucas and any others I may have forgotten that saw through Sophie from the very start. Well done!

by RIPLucas
» Thu Sep 1 2016 11:32:25
IMDb member since October 2002
My guess is Sophie.

Cam's story of how they met...it stuck with me. He was seeing her at places and eventually she just walked up to him and said "Hello, I'm going to be your girlfriend". It's almost as if she was studying him before finally making her move.

There's also their son. We know that Jack most definitely requires professional help, and Sophie seems at least a little unstable as well. Perhaps this is a trait passed down through HER family, even if we are originally led to believe it came through Cam.

My theory is the SBK was her father, and once he vanished and Mitch killed in SBKs name she realized that the Hawthorne family did something to him. Her relationship with Cam is a way to stay close to the family and wait to see if she could find something to lead her to her father.

Naturally I could be wrong. Maybe I even missed her mentioning her parents, who knows. We'll all find out next week!

[–] SquidNewton 8 years ago

Definitely YES!!

Well done!!

[–] AtheistRevolution 8 years ago

From the start I thought it was either Sophie,Madeline or Alison. They all seemed like sociopaths. Especially with that future serial killer kid. Of course it turned out they all had a hand in killing. So this show had a lot of female killers.

Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by rulers as useful.