Nitpicking, but couldn't they get the wardrobes right?
This show is always on the air somewhere - they couldn't have referenced it for the wardrobes? For example: the Spring Fling dresses that were identical, but different colors and nowhere near the styles of the actual dresses.
And why was the Slumber Party confession outside in some field and not in the Walsh living room?
Casting was good (except for Brian Austin Green - I didn't know who he was supposed to be until they finally said his name), staying close to the actual true-to-life events was good, but the wardrobe really irritated me.
The Jennie and Shannen actresses were excellent - hopefully if they make a Charmed, they'll cast this girl again.