MovieChat Forums > Goldstone (2018) Discussion > Goldstone or Mystery Road

Goldstone or Mystery Road


Which did you think was better? I loved both but I might have to give the edge to Goldstone.

reply

Mystery Road, by far.

This felt like a retread.

reply

Mystery Road for sure. That wasn't a great film by any means but this was just sh!t.

reply

Mystery Road was much better. I think I voted that movie a 7. This one I gave a 5 and thats being awfully sympathetic. I probably should have given it a 4.

reply

Why do you think Goldstone was "sh!t", Maverick368?

KR

reply

Mystery Road had a more developed story and more fully realized characters (Johnno, for example). This one was still good, but maybe one level below Mystery Road.

reply

Goldstone was a 7 for me and checking back I gave 8 to Mystery Road, but to be honest I enjoyed both equally so edited Goldstone to an 8 also.

reply

I give Goldstone the edge, but only just. Its shorter and I find it tackles some more interesting themes

reply

Liked Goldstone better.

reply

Mystery Road by far. This was just a mediocre washup of the first instalment. Still better than many other new films coming out, though.

reply

Goldstone isn't bad but Mystery Road I think is better. Aaron Pedersen is excellent in both though

reply

Both are really slow but i personally don't mind that at all if the pay off is worth it

I thought Mystery Road was really hard to follow at times but the characters were more realistic and it was quite grounded

Goldstone reminded me of a Clint Eastwood type film the baddies were a bit overly evil in an obvious way i thought with the mayor ect, having said that i think i preferred it i liked the arc of the young Cop and the trafficking aspect

The racism aspect is a little over done as well i get that's the whole premise but it was a little heavy handed in parts

Really liked Hugo Weaving's 'Turn' as well i did't see that coming

reply

Give the series a try, too....

reply