Lights Out or The Darkness

Lights out!

Lights Out for the easy victory. I didn't hate The Darkness (any movie with Radha Mitchell and Kevin Bacon is guaranteed to have likeable leads), but it contained little suspense, no scares, and lame villains. Lights Out was not a perfect film by any stretch of the imagination, but in addition to having leads whom I cared about and rooted for, it maintained solid suspense, tension, and atmosphere, and Diana was a far more menacing and effective villain than those demons in The Darkness.