MovieChat Forums > Stranger Things (2016) Discussion > All of the "high school" kids are actual...

All of the "high school" kids are actually college age or older.


Steve, Nancy, Jonathan and Billy are all played by actors in their twenties, in or around college age. This annoys me. Why can't high school students be played by actual high schoolers? Also, when people watch shows like this, I think their ability to guess other people's ages is affected negatively. Now, when people see college-age students in their twenties, they are going to think they are teenagers and treat them as such.

reply

Has to do with child labor laws.

reply

I don't understand. The middle-schoolers are played by actual teenagers and they seem to have just as much screen time as the college-aged actors. Where do the child labor laws factor in there?

reply

20 year olds can pass as high schoolers. With younger kids, itโ€™s generally not easy to find adults who can play them.

reply

I can't make any sense of this reply. All of the young kids in this show (Mike, Lucas, Dustin, Eleven, Max) are, in fact, played by young kids.

reply

Which part don't you understand?

You can't get a 20 year old to play a 12 year old, but you can get some to pass for 16 or 17. The Child labour laws limit the amount the kids can work. They have to have a parent or guardian with them at all times. It's less hassle for the production/ studios to work with adults than kids. That's why almost all teenagers are played by adults in these types of shows.

reply

Right. A twenty year old can pass for seventeen and doesn't have to follow child labor laws that limit when and how much a kid can work.

But you just can't find many adults who can play a twelve year old.

reply

It's acting. They can all pass as high school students, so what's the harm? I seriously doubt anyone is going to start treating college students like high school students, whatever that means, after watching Stranger Things.

reply

I don't see the problem. Seniors in high-school are generally 18 years old. Someone in their early 20's are not that far removed from high-school. They picked great actors/actresses for all the roles. Not like they're 30 years old.

reply

They don't want to show actual teenagers having sex on screen, so they decided to use older actors...

Also, it is common for shows to use early 20s actors as teens, since it makes the teens look even more sexually developed and if the show goes on for longer their looks don't change drastically in a period of months or a year...

Also, 20 year olds today probably only look like late teens in the 80s, as the 80s had a more adult feel than the very infantilised times we live in now... ๐Ÿ˜‰

reply

It's a common trick of the trade used in show business. People like actors that look younger than they really are, so they can have them play younger roles, but have the maturity and reliability that comes with an older age. This is done all the time, where the actors playing kids or teenagers are actually much older than their character. It's especially helpful that for a lot of young adults, there actually isn't much physical changeover from high school to college during the first few years, beyond changing hair and clothes. There are also some people who have a genetic trait that we in the vernacular call being "baby-faced," where they look younger than they really are. Some examples would include:

- Billie Burke playing a seemingly ageless [20/30/40-something] Glinda in "The Wizard of Oz" when she was in her 50s

- Gary Burghoff playing a 19-year-old Radar on "M*A*S*H" in his 30s

- Michael J. Fox playing a teenaged Marty McFly on "Back to the Future" in his late 20s/early30s

- Jennifer Lawrence playing a 16-year-old Katniss in the first "Hunger Games" movie when she was 20

- Kirsten Storms playing a 13-year-old Zenon in "Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century" when she was 15

- Melissa Joan Hart playing 16-year-old Sabrina when she was already in her early 20s when the tv show started

- the little boy actor in "Heaven Is For Real" playing a 4-year-old child, when he in fact is 6

Sadly, not all film/tv makers are good at choosing young-looking actors, if that awful film "Grease" is anything to go by. They also play on the fact that most viewers are not experts in what people of certain ages look like.

reply

Maybe it's a throwback to the high school/college movies of the 80's. When the actors played teenagers but were in fact closer to 30.

reply

There's nothing new about that. I could pass myself off as a teenager well into my late 20s.

reply

Some have played high schoolers even though they were in their thirties!!!

reply