MovieChat Forums > Little Women: NY (2015) Discussion > that brokers fee on the apt.?

that brokers fee on the apt.?


as a home owner, not really in touch on such things but 15% of a entire years rent?
2900 X 12 = 34,800 X 15% = 5,220 seem outragous to me, not to mention the yearly salary has to be 40 times rent.
glad i own!

reply

When she said the rent was $2,900.00 a month that alone woke me up! So I just got schooled on "cost of living" "size of apts" broker's fee". First I live in Georgia...about 70 miles south of Atlanta. I own my home and without giving too much personal information out those figures were CRAZY!! So all you people that live where that amount doesn't floor you please tell me more! Was that typical? So what do apts rent for....like our apt complexes here range from 2 bdrms 2 baths about 1200 sq ft $750~$800! Those are gated with amenities. Now in Atlanta it's different. so what's up?

reply

I know! F that. I've lived all over this country and I would have found a different way to find an apartment than to go through brokers taking that much money. I don't know if that is a NYC thing, but I wouldn't deal with brokers for renting. You're renting, not buying. That amount of money up front for a damn apartment broker is robbery.

My mortgage broker didn't even take that amount of money when I bought my first house last year.

reply

Jason's yearly salary would have to be $1,392,000!?! That's 40 x $34,800.

reply

40x the monthly rent. Not yearly.

reply

New York is EXPENSIVE! Cost of living should be higher there though, meaning wages for more than min. wage positions should be adjusted. But yeah that apartment price was insane to me. Where I am a single bedroom apartment (that is remotely nice) is gonna cost probably $800, and a 2 BD a little more. However, the closer into DC I get, the higher the prices. But even in DC they aren't over 2K for a 1 BD. Over 1K though. Not sure why the fee was 15% though. That is very high. Normally it's one month and a security deposit. Also how could they need to make 40x the rent?! Are we sure she didn't say 4x? Even that is a lot though. But yeah in NY, near the city, pretty sure finding apartments is a huge pain. I know regarding the show Friends people always complained it was unrealistic for them to have been able to get such nice apartments so easily.

reply

I thought I heard 40 as well, but 4 makes a lot more sense. I could see a person according the apartment Jason looked at on $139,200 a year.

reply

I could swear the realtor person said 40 times as well or I wouldn't of bothered mentioning it. on the weekends they always run those semi- marathons maybe somebody will catch it again.

reply

It was 4x when i rented my first place in calif. However she did say 40x. I rewatched it with closed captioning. Also 40x2900 is $116,000. She just rounded up.

reply

In NYC, brokers, a 15% fee of a year's rent, and the requirement to make 40x the monthly rent are the norm when it comes to renting an apartment. It's a challenge to find an apartment without a broker here - you really have to hunt and save up a good chunk of change before you move regardless. And apartments go lightning fast, and a fee-free one goes even faster. Even if you don't actually deal with a broker during your search, a landlord will often work with one to run the paperwork and screen potential renters, and so you will end up paying the broker's fee anyway even if the broker did absolutely nothing for you. It's just the way it is.

In terms of wage adjustments, the median yearly income is also just above $52,000 for all of NYC (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/18/nyregion/gap-between-manhattans-rich-and-poor-is-greatest-in-us-census-finds.html). It's a really tough city to afford and wages are also fairly stagnant. One thing to keep in mind, though, is that most people in NYC do not have cars - we are not making car payments, paying property tax on a car, or making insurance payments. So that is one cost we don't have (though a monthly metro pass is $116 and we pay three taxes - city, state, and federal). We also have rent stabilization in which the rent increases on designated apartment buildings are regulated in terms of how much of a percentage a landlord can raise the rent for a lease renewal. With these kinds of apartments, heat and water are usually included in the rent.

Manhattan is out of reach for most people, and the parts of Brooklyn and Queens nearest Manhattan are getting to be just as expensive. I'm curious to know what neighborhood the girls who lived way uptown is - my guess is Washington Heights or Inwood. They are definitely more rough around the edges (I live there) than lower Manhattan but people there are no more dangerous than in any other part of the city. Is it rich and white? No. But that doesn't equate to unsafe. In fact, it has a more neighborhood-y, community feel than the commercialized, gentrified parts of the lower half of Manhattan, and it is really quite lovely. And the apartments are relatively spacious and affordable! "Upstate Manhattan" (as I call it) is a feasible area for Jason to set his sights on.

And I, too, grew up in and am from the DC area, so these prices are still crazy to me as well! But here I still am, 10 years on...

reply

I agree, I live in California and own my home - I feel the same. Talk about being schooled. It has been years, since I have rented in California, so I can't imagine renting in New York. I feel very grateful for my home.

reply

I was born and raised in CA but when I moved out my parents house, I moved to MS. To have the same apartment I have here and live a similar life, my fiance and I would have to make $65-70k a year. At the moment we maybe make 40K (and that's optimistic.) I soo want to move back but it's not looking like that'll happen any time soon.

Even knowing all that, I think the numbers that the Realtor threw out were INSANE. I knew NYC was expensive but hot damn.

reply

Okay, I think a small fee is reasonable because the realtors do have to do the searching for the client but the cost she quoted seemed awfully expensive. A lot of us viewers probably widened our eyes when we heard the cost of that apt. wow
I for one am glad I don't live in NY because I couldn't afford a 1 bedroom apt. or maybe even a studio apt. (in a safe area) It makes me appreciate having a house that is paid off.

reply

I agree. And in NY they have taken over the city. They won't even show you anything if you don't have enough money to cover like a year's rent or have a person to co-sign for you.

I grew up here - my father was born in Manhattan - and I have to deal with some whiny guy from another state who makes money off of me?

It is such a scam. And it's legal. That is the worst part.

reply

New York is a very expensive place to live. A lot of residents have moved away due to the high cost of living there.

reply