MovieChat Forums > Second Chance (2016) Discussion > Basic genetics is taught in high school....

Basic genetics is taught in high school...


...so how do they not know that a gene doesn't skip a generation, but a genetic trait does. And, if it had skipped a generation and appeared in the next, it's not that special, because Duval's wife had to have had it to pass it on to Gracie.

Fighting a religious war is like fighting over whose imaginary friend is better.

reply

That means that their math is wrong as well.

1% of the US population is ~3 million people. 1%. The precursor is a 1 in 1 million thing, right? So... statistically (with everyone spread out equally and the precursor people sprinkled in perfectly), living in the state of Washington alone, there would be ~6 people with the precursor. Add in Oregon's ~3(.9) million and California's 38(.8) million, there would be ~47 people on the west coast with the precursor. Not just two.

Unless I did math wrong. That happens sometimes.

On another note, wouldn't Duval's wife only have to be a carrier of the precursor and not *have* to have it. It's still like a 1/4 chance, but...


reply

wouldn't Duval's wife only have to be a carrier of the precursor and not *have* to have it.


Yes. The precursor gene would have to be recessive, and Duval and his wife only carriers.

Fighting a religious war is like fighting over whose imaginary friend is better.

reply

Isn't it possible that the gene in this case ISN'T Mendelian? For example, eye color isn't Mendelian. You could have a person with blue eyes, but both his father and daughter have green eyes. Maybe the genetic precursor requires a specific combination of genetic markers. Most things aren't just one gene.

reply